This article says that Joan of Arc "led" troops, which would be news to her since she denied calling herself a commander when the issue came up at her trial, confirmed by numerous eyewitness accounts: she advised the commanders but did not have direct command and was frustrated when the commanders refused her advice.
Re: "Jeanne d'Arc': even aside from the inclusion of monsters etc, the mundane elements are also erroneous on many points (Joan of Arc didn't personally fight in combat, the maps are all wrong, the basic outline of her battles is wrong, etc).
"Jeanne d'Arc" not only adds monsters to the Hundred Years War, but also erroneously makes Joan of Arc into a fighter, which was denied by both Joan herself and the numerous eyewitness accounts which all describe her carrying her banner in battle rather than fighting, and she bluntly denied fighting.
"The Passion of Joan of Arc" may have been well done in terms of cinematography, but in terms of historical accuracy it relied far too heavily on a single document (the trial transcript) which is contradicted on important points by virtually everything else. Many eyewitnesses who were at Joan of Arc's trial said that the English government manipulated the trial (as we also know from English government records) and the transcript was falsified on crucial issues such as her alleged refusal to submit to the Church (which the eyewitnesses said wasn't true), her alleged reasons for clinging to her soldier's outfit (which she said, as quoted by eyewitnesses, was to allow her to keep it laced up into one piece to prevent her guards from pulling her clothing off), and many other issues. The film may be better than most of the more recent films on the subject, but it isn't accurate.
This article claims Joan of Arc (Jeanne d'Arc) was executed as a witch, but if you look at the trial transcript you'll see that the witchcraft charges had been dropped before the final set of 12 accusations were drawn up. She was convicted for "relapsing" into wearing a soldier's riding outfit, which the bailiff, Jehan Massieu, said was the result of the guards taking away her dress and forcing her to put the soldier's clothing back on, then the pro-English judge used that as an excuse to condemn her. The inclusion of Amelia Earheart and Marie Antoinette as "witches" is even more bizarre.
My Posts(5)
Baz Luhrmann Has Found His Joan Of Arc For New Movie
This article says that Joan of Arc "led" troops, which would be news to her since she denied calling herself a commander when the issue came up at her trial, confirmed by numerous eyewitness accounts: she advised the commanders but did not have direct command and was frustrated when the commanders refused her advice.
10 Greatest PSP Games Of All Time (#3 Is A Masterpiece)
Re: "Jeanne d'Arc': even aside from the inclusion of monsters etc, the mundane elements are also erroneous on many points (Joan of Arc didn't personally fight in combat, the maps are all wrong, the basic outline of her battles is wrong, etc).
10 Best PS Plus Classics To Play Right Now
"Jeanne d'Arc" not only adds monsters to the Hundred Years War, but also erroneously makes Joan of Arc into a fighter, which was denied by both Joan herself and the numerous eyewitness accounts which all describe her carrying her banner in battle rather than fighting, and she bluntly denied fighting.
10 Classic Black & White Movie Performances That Left Us Mesmerized
"The Passion of Joan of Arc" may have been well done in terms of cinematography, but in terms of historical accuracy it relied far too heavily on a single document (the trial transcript) which is contradicted on important points by virtually everything else. Many eyewitnesses who were at Joan of Arc's trial said that the English government manipulated the trial (as we also know from English government records) and the transcript was falsified on crucial issues such as her alleged refusal to submit to the Church (which the eyewitnesses said wasn't true), her alleged reasons for clinging to her soldier's outfit (which she said, as quoted by eyewitnesses, was to allow her to keep it laced up into one piece to prevent her guards from pulling her clothing off), and many other issues. The film may be better than most of the more recent films on the subject, but it isn't accurate.
-
Fans Waiting for Record of Ragnarok Season 3 Need To Read This Witch Tournament Manga
This article claims Joan of Arc (Jeanne d'Arc) was executed as a witch, but if you look at the trial transcript you'll see that the witchcraft charges had been dropped before the final set of 12 accusations were drawn up. She was convicted for "relapsing" into wearing a soldier's riding outfit, which the bailiff, Jehan Massieu, said was the result of the guards taking away her dress and forcing her to put the soldier's clothing back on, then the pro-English judge used that as an excuse to condemn her. The inclusion of Amelia Earheart and Marie Antoinette as "witches" is even more bizarre.