Latest Posts(17)
See All18 Years Later, The Best TV Episode Of All Time Still Keeps Me Awake At Night
I love comments like this, not a single show had their ending planned beyond an image of the closing moments, like, for example, they knew the series would end with Jack closing his eyes to mirror the opening scene of the show, they also knew that the light and dark theme would be personified, but, because it was network TV, they had to delay the answers until they got the go-ahead to progress their story (from mid-season 3 onward, which is where the endgame is hinted at).
Not many endings satisfy the fans, and when it is a mythology-based show, the praise for the ending is often mixed-negative. What annoys me is how Twin Peaks got away with mystery-box storytelling, to the point it ended its run with one of the single worst finales of all time, but, because it is David Lynch, it's a masterpiece that audiences "don't need to understand and just need to go with, because it's Lynchian genius!"..... The irony is that Lindelof, the creator of LOST, literally got his writing style from his adoration of Lynch.
And finally, I've seen from your comments that you like Pluribus, a show that couldn't even sustain a short 9 episode season without meandering with pointless endeavours because it clearly fails to figure out what kind of show it even wants to be, but, a show that also had the creator admit that he is struggling to figure out a solution to the big problem that ended the season, and, regrets even including it, so, even Vince Gilligan didn't learn from LOST, it seems. At least Damon Lindelof admits that even if he doesn't intend to include it in his shows, he would never put a random mystery in his shows without having an answer for it (Proven with the idea that the Hatch was a JJ Abrams idea, who even wanted the pilot of LOST to end with the discovery, but Damon refused to ever include it until he decided he knew what was inside the Hatch, which is why it came at the mid-point of season 1).
This Is The Greatest Sci-Fi TV Show Of All Time - Prove Me Wrong
He even has a rule that no mystery was ever gonna be written into the show unless he himself has an answer to it, JJ was the one that came up with the concept of them finding a hatch with Quarantine written on it, and he wanted the characters to find it in the pilot episode, Damon refused to include it in the show until he himself had figured out an answer to that question.
You're all clueless if you think the show didn't provide answers, or a satisfying conclusion, it's the greatest show, and ending, in all of TV, Breaking Bad spent its finale focusing on one character, Walt, they even had to make a movie to give Jesse his dues (despite Gilligan stating that the fate of Jesse was purposefully left for the audience decide), whereas, LOST had to juggle a gazillion characters, dead and alive, and to provide the answer to something that was impossible to answer, what the Island is. It's like explaining what the world is and why we exist as a species.
This Is The Greatest Sci-Fi TV Show Of All Time - Prove Me Wrong
3.
I get the impression that 1 or more of you don't understand the ending, just FYI, whatever happened, happened, nothing was a dream, nothing was meaningless, if the Man in Black succeeded and left the Island, he would've spread his darkness all over the world, resulting in everyone being "claimed" and becoming like Sayid and Claire.
The flash sideways were the only part of the story that had no merit on the main arc, because it was about all of the characters finding one another in death and moving on. It was basically an epilogue, a resolution for all of the characters.
4. B5 didn't influence LOST, shows like Twin Peaks did, which brings me to my next point, how come David Lynch can get away with not providing answers to questions and leaving everything open, but Damon Lindelof, a guy that got his writing technique from the crazy mind of David Lynch, can't allow for interpretation and open-ended mysteries? LOST never promised you answers, that wasn't Lindelof, that was the marketing department at ABC, they are the ones that created those trailers for the seasons and episodes. They did a similar thing in season 3 of the show, where they promised an answer to an important question, and, not only was it an answer for Jack's tattoo, it was the worst episode of the entire series.
5.
Damon never said that the entire show was leading to definitive answers, he has always been purposefully vague in what he wants to reveal in the show, to the point in which he even kept it vague for the commentary of Across the Sea and the possibility of Mother being the duelling light and dark and being a smoke monster herself, which is why Jacob's mistake that he made was the split of both light and dark, creating evil incarnate in the shape of his brother
This Is The Greatest Sci-Fi TV Show Of All Time - Prove Me Wrong
Buckeye, Tom, Justin & Brian....
You're all incapable of understand nuance in writing, or understanding what facts are, since nothing you lot said was even close to the truth:
1. JJ Abrams didn't run the show, he left the show after the pilot to work on Mission Impossible III, and gave showrunner duties to Damon Lindelof, who remained until the show's closing moments, bringing in Carlton Cuse after a stressful time in which he would pray the show would be cancelled cause he had never ran a show before and felt the job was daunting, having to come up with a new idea every week for 20+ weeks (He spoke candidly about this on the Kevin Pollack Show).
2. The show explained everything, whether directly or indirectly, the show provided an answer to every question they posed, they just did not sit you down to explain it all like the Architect in the Matrix (another thing Damon has stated was influential in how he refuses to give exposition to answers). The worst answer they directly confirmed was the Whispers, and that is because they had Hurley randomly say "I know what they mean", it boxed in a world of possibilities for what those whispers were, to a singular reason, and I find answers like that are the issue. Not explaining the Whispers allows for more interpretation over the 6 seasons on whether you think they were dead people trapped on the Island that can't move on due to unfinished business, part of the Smoke Monster's manipulation, The Others messing with you, or your own subconscious mind getting to you like it does with Sawyer with the "it'll come back around". The only mystery the show seemed to skip over was who the outrigger shooters were. Everything else was answered. You clearly just missed the point.
This Is The Greatest Sci-Fi TV Show Of All Time - Prove Me Wrong
It's not even the greatest British TV show.
I will never understand the undying love for this show. It is truly one of the biggest mysteries of life how grown adults can watch it and think it is on the level of LOST, BSG, Fringe, X-Files, Supernatural. It's one of those shows that I just think is for kids that never grew up.
It's why the hate for the newer stuff always makes me laugh, because the show has never been well-written, so, calling it "bad writing" today is just like a kid realising Santa wasn't real.
8 Episodes Of The X-Files I Always Skip On A Rewatch
Re-watching 3 but never watching Home is some crazy choice.