As a devout fan of the books for over thirty years, the adaptation was pretty good… but not phenomenal. It may have been because I had listened to the full cast audiobooks prior to watching, but I found Dafne’s Lyra far too serious and subdued, not the dynamic character from the books. And don’t get me started on trying to pass Lin-Manuel Miranda off as a Texan. Love the guy, but nothing could beat the movie’s perfectly cast Sam Elliott as Lee Scoresby.
This is a fun thought experiment, and some of the choices are interesting, but do you really think they’re gonna reboot the whole dang thing? And look, I’m not a Dany stan or anything but I’m laughing at the thought of “a crucial role in a Gossip Girl reboot” as good credentials to play Daenerys Targaryen.
I’m a Mulder/Scully diehard currently rewatching the show for the first time in twenty years. While the chemistry between the two was entirely why the original show worked, I’m willing to give Patel and Deadwyler a chance, if only because everything Ryan Coogler touches is gold. However I don’t know if I want Mulder/Scully cameos… I feel like it wouldn’t allow the new show to stand on its own (as is the case with so many reboots/prequels/spin-offs), but I still can’t imagine it working without them.
The first two seasons of Arrow are some of the best superhero TV of all time. When the creative team started splitting off to do spinoffs things never were quite as tight, but nothing will ever beat the magic lightning-in-a-bottle chemistry of Original Team Arrow which formed the backbone of the entire Arrowverse.
As a huge fan of His Dark Materials I was disappointed by the adaptation. And as a screenwriting MFA I understand how adaptations work, and I understand the changes they made to make the storyline work for television, I just didn’t care for them. And while I love Dafne Keene (she was excellent in Logan) I felt she was too old to play Lyra and her portrayal was too self serious—Lyra is exuberant where Dane played it subdued. And again, I love Lin Manuel Miranda, but under no circumstances was he well cast as Lee Scorseby, a Texan aeronaut, especially compared to the film’s perfect casting of Sam Elliott.
This is… a very mid list. Not great choices, order is all over the place,and the title is a misnomer: “peak TV” refers to TV during the mid-2010s when networks were making more scripted TV shows than ever before, noting that the “bubble” would burst,as it has. Perhaps you mean “prestige TV,” which is about quality, both in actuality and perception.
The thing is Fire and Blood is… um… Not Good from a narrative point. Too many conflicting accounts told after the fact so there’s no distinct first person perspective like in the original series. It was supposed to be up to the era to figure out what were the Definitive Events of the story—what *really* happened. The show takes this conflicting account and shows everything like it’s the definitive version, and that weakens the source material and the point that it is up to the reader to figure out what’s real and what’s propaganda.
That and the legacy of GoT are the true weaknesses of the series—the need to make Rhaenyra the righteous Chosen One to make up for the fan backlash about Daenerys’s story and the prophecy as connecting tissue to the original series makes it harder for HotD to stand on its own.
THIS is how you be an ally. If I wasn’t completely in love with Ben Barnes before, I am so impressed by him now, especially after the disappointment of seeing who’s associating with that woman because of the audiobooks. Thanks, I don’t need any new HP anything, and I really don’t want to support someone who denigrates the humanity of others.
Even before Altered Carbon, Dichen was stealing hearts and proving her sci-fi chops in Dollhouse, one of Whedon’s lesser shows where she was an absolute highlight.
I can only dream that Spike comes back (James sure has been coy about it!) but my big three returns I NEED are Tara, Cordelia and Anya. Now that J*ss is no longer involved, I’d dearly love to see Charisma come back, especially with how Cordelia’s story ended.
This list is golden, for once. The Good Place set up the rest of the series, Severance made my jaw drop and Jack’s “WE HAVE TO GO BACK!” lives rent free in my brain almost 20 years later.
Severance gave some of the same vibes as Lost, and the weekly conversation was the closest I’ve come to the experience of watching List in real time as it first aired, which I thoroughly enjoyed even as the show proved to be a flawed masterpiece.
Who mustard Wars when Johnson is doing brilliant work elsewhere? I forgot TV could be as fun as Poker Face is every week, and why would he go back after the fanboy crybaby reactions he got?
My Posts(19)
HBO's 23-Part Masterpiece Is Hands Down Fantasy's Best Live-Action Adaptation
As a devout fan of the books for over thirty years, the adaptation was pretty good… but not phenomenal. It may have been because I had listened to the full cast audiobooks prior to watching, but I found Dafne’s Lyra far too serious and subdued, not the dynamic character from the books. And don’t get me started on trying to pass Lin-Manuel Miranda off as a Texan. Love the guy, but nothing could beat the movie’s perfectly cast Sam Elliott as Lee Scoresby.
HBO Is Officially Making TV History With New Fantasy Series Set To Run For Over A Decade
No one needed another HP adaptation, and we’re only getting one because of Joanne’s political agenda and WB being bankrupt of new, original ideas.
Recasting Game Of Thrones For 2026: All 10 Main Characters
This is a fun thought experiment, and some of the choices are interesting, but do you really think they’re gonna reboot the whole dang thing? And look, I’m not a Dany stan or anything but I’m laughing at the thought of “a crucial role in a Gossip Girl reboot” as good credentials to play Daenerys Targaryen.
The X-Files Switching Casts After 33 Years Is A Double-Edged Sword
I’m a Mulder/Scully diehard currently rewatching the show for the first time in twenty years. While the chemistry between the two was entirely why the original show worked, I’m willing to give Patel and Deadwyler a chance, if only because everything Ryan Coogler touches is gold. However I don’t know if I want Mulder/Scully cameos… I feel like it wouldn’t allow the new show to stand on its own (as is the case with so many reboots/prequels/spin-offs), but I still can’t imagine it working without them.
Every Arrowverse TV Show, Ranked From Worst To Best
The first two seasons of Arrow are some of the best superhero TV of all time. When the creative team started splitting off to do spinoffs things never were quite as tight, but nothing will ever beat the magic lightning-in-a-bottle chemistry of Original Team Arrow which formed the backbone of the entire Arrowverse.
HBO's 10/10 Fantasy Masterpiece Shows Game Of Thrones How It's Done
As a huge fan of His Dark Materials I was disappointed by the adaptation. And as a screenwriting MFA I understand how adaptations work, and I understand the changes they made to make the storyline work for television, I just didn’t care for them. And while I love Dafne Keene (she was excellent in Logan) I felt she was too old to play Lyra and her portrayal was too self serious—Lyra is exuberant where Dane played it subdued. And again, I love Lin Manuel Miranda, but under no circumstances was he well cast as Lee Scorseby, a Texan aeronaut, especially compared to the film’s perfect casting of Sam Elliott.
20 HBO Shows That Deserve Their Masterpiece Status
This is… a very mid list. Not great choices, order is all over the place,and the title is a misnomer: “peak TV” refers to TV during the mid-2010s when networks were making more scripted TV shows than ever before, noting that the “bubble” would burst,as it has. Perhaps you mean “prestige TV,” which is about quality, both in actuality and perception.
10/10 Pilot Episodes Are Rare, But These 10 Shows Had Perfect Beginnings
Pretty good list—I’d have a few quibbles about ranking maybe, and only add the Veronica Mars and Freaks and Geeks pilots as numbers eleven and twelve.
10/10 Pilot Episodes Are Rare, But These 10 Shows Had Perfect Beginnings
Such a good pilot! Real tragedy the show was so short-lived!
House Of The Dragon's Risky Franchise-First Can Make Or Break Season 3
The thing is Fire and Blood is… um… Not Good from a narrative point. Too many conflicting accounts told after the fact so there’s no distinct first person perspective like in the original series. It was supposed to be up to the era to figure out what were the Definitive Events of the story—what *really* happened. The show takes this conflicting account and shows everything like it’s the definitive version, and that weakens the source material and the point that it is up to the reader to figure out what’s real and what’s propaganda.
That and the legacy of GoT are the true weaknesses of the series—the need to make Rhaenyra the righteous Chosen One to make up for the fan backlash about Daenerys’s story and the prophecy as connecting tissue to the original series makes it harder for HotD to stand on its own.
10 TV Shows That Didn't Live Up To Their Amazing First Seasons
Season 2 of Fargo is by far the best the show has ever been. Season 5 was also surprisingly good.
Shadow And Bone Star Addresses Being An Age-Old Harry Potter Fancast Amid Ongoing J.K. Rowling Controversy
THIS is how you be an ally. If I wasn’t completely in love with Ben Barnes before, I am so impressed by him now, especially after the disappointment of seeing who’s associating with that woman because of the audiobooks. Thanks, I don’t need any new HP anything, and I really don’t want to support someone who denigrates the humanity of others.
Severance Audition Video Reveals Ms. Casey Was Originally Much Darker Than What We Saw
Even before Altered Carbon, Dichen was stealing hearts and proving her sci-fi chops in Dollhouse, one of Whedon’s lesser shows where she was an absolute highlight.
8 Great TV Episodes That You'll Never Want To Rewatch (Number 1 Is Heartbreaking)
Nothing will ever devastate the way The Body did on Buffy. Twenty years later it still sticks with me.
After Sarah Michelle Gellar's Comments, These 9 Dead Buffy Characters Should Return In The Reboot
I can only dream that Spike comes back (James sure has been coy about it!) but my big three returns I NEED are Tara, Cordelia and Anya. Now that J*ss is no longer involved, I’d dearly love to see Charisma come back, especially with how Cordelia’s story ended.
10 Incredible TV Show Twists That Are Nothing Short Of Genius
This list is golden, for once. The Good Place set up the rest of the series, Severance made my jaw drop and Jack’s “WE HAVE TO GO BACK!” lives rent free in my brain almost 20 years later.
20 Best HBO Episodes Of All Time, Ranked
Surprised to not see “International Assassin” from The Leftovers on here, but it is a lesser known show I guess.
15 Years After Lost Ended, These 8 TV Shows Are The Best Replacements
Severance gave some of the same vibes as Lost, and the weekly conversation was the closest I’ve come to the experience of watching List in real time as it first aired, which I thoroughly enjoyed even as the show proved to be a flawed masterpiece.
Eight Years After The Last Jedi, Rian Johnson Gives Disappointing Update On His Star Wars Future
Who mustard Wars when Johnson is doing brilliant work elsewhere? I forgot TV could be as fun as Poker Face is every week, and why would he go back after the fanboy crybaby reactions he got?