SRMember
#FS036438
Follow
Followed
Following:
0
Topics
0
Users
Reviews
0
Ratings
0
My Posts(1)
Alien: Romulus Review - Horrifying Sci-Fi Actioner Has The Best (& Worst) Of The Alien Franchise
I hate to rain on the parade, but this movie was a travesty. Some stunning visuals and decent action scenes spare it from being a COMPLETE failure, but only just. It blows it on the basics of the first two movies: (1) The Nostromo was vaporized in a nuclear explosion. There would be no wreckage to be found. (2) The alien was nowhere near the Nostromo when it was vaporized - it was far away with Ripley on the escape ship - so its body couldn't be drifting with the Nostromo wreckage, which couldn't exist. (3) The alien wasn't just blown out an airlock, as Rook tells us. It too was vaporized when it tried to crawl back into the escape ship through the thrusters, so there could be no intact alien body drifting with the non-existent Nostromo wreckage. (4) According to Rook, the Nostromo events happened 20 years before the events of Romulus, but we learn at the beginning of Aliens that Ripley was adrift for 57 years. So how does Rook know there was "one survivor" of the Nostromo, and that the Alien was blown out an airlock?
And those are just the obvious - and infuriatingly needless - inconsistencies with the existing storyline. The rest of the movie is largely an incoherent mashup of what came before, from borrowing wholly intact lines of dialogue ("You have my sympathies"), to plot devices (returning down the elevator of a crumbling space structure - with one gun low on ammunition - to rescue a "family member" who is not a family member), to visual imagery (the human / alien hybrid of Resurrection, complete with licking its "mother"), to the characters themselves (Ash / Rook). These aren't "hat tips" or "Easter eggs." They're lazy, and they're thrown together in a senseless mess.
And did my eyes deceive me, or did we see visual references to the DNA soup and the creator race from Prometheus and Covenant? How is that possible?
Extremely disappointing.