Latest Posts(4)
See All8 Sitcoms From The 2000s That Have Aged Horribly
David "Space"?
Maybe the reason these sitcoms don't work today is the erosion of a sense of ironic humor. It's like watching "All in the Family" and complaining that it promoted bigotry.
You could view these male characters the way Archie Bunker is viewed -- not as someone to emulate but rather as comically absurd characters.
Star Trek’s OG Character Change Makes Strange New Worlds Season 4 Even More Important
The whole idea of Spock being this unhinged emotional mess is based, I assume, on the scenes of the original pilot where he is portrayed as smiling and acting with less restraint. But that wasn't the fully formed character that was ultimately developed by the writers and Nimoy -- it was abandoned in favor of the more restrained version. There was no indication of some kind of transformation. Note this exchange between Spock and his mother:
Amanda: "After all these years with humans, you still haven't learned to smile."
Spock: "Humans smile with so little provocation."
Unless Spock was hiding his emotional self from his family, why would his mother say that, expressing her disappointment in her son's inability to acknowledge his human half? Abandoning this important element of continuity, the portrayal of Spock as emotionally unhinged flies in the face of what his mother had said.
You could argue that Roddenberry's cannibalizing the first pilot was itself a mistake. The two part episode was a bad fit in one significant way: Spock's violation of regulation was clearly out of character. His actions should not have been waved off but rather addressed as a major point of concern about his psychological state.
Putting all that aside, the shallow-minded exploitation of familiar characters transformed into cartoon versions for the sake of "fun" totally misses the point of Trek. It was the gravitas of those characters, restrained by their sense of duty and discipline, and how their humanity emerged through their actions, that added a depth to the stories. SNW lacks that insight. The characters tend to behave without restraint, which is not the way those facing risk and danger would or should act.
There is a reason for following protocol and chain of command which the writers fail to acknowledge. The degradation of Spock's character is an example of that. No amount of character adjustment at this point will make up for that.
One Star Trek: The Original Series Episode Shouldn't Be Considered Canon
Time travel has always been somewhat problematic in Trek. For people to casually travel back in time, with all the risks of changing the time line, it just opens the door to various inconsistencies. Once the timeline is contaminated, maintaining the original narrative becomes a stretch.
As an example, ST: First Contact raises the question, why wouldn't the Borg try to go into the past repeatedly to change Earth's history until they got it right?
The only instance of time travel that makes sense would be the "City on the Edge of Forever" scenario. The Guardian was apparently able to prevent the landing party from being affected by the changes that took place when McCoy disrupted the timeline, having an ability to bring them out of the timeline and giving them the option to correct it. Done this way it did not trigger the non-sequiturs -- it had a role as a guardian of time and a level of technology that should have been beyond the Federation or the Borg.
If I were to reboot Star Trek I would avoid time travel and only use it in instances that did not involve the possibility of it being used casually by humans, Borg, or any other species with a temporal ax to grind.
Bookie Season 3: Cancelation & Everything We Know
Great series -- funniest I've seen in a while. Really bummed it's been cancelled. Need to find a way to bring it back.