So I can see how a lot of people are super fans.. I get it, I absolutely am obsessed with the 1st and 2nd books! I agree with some of these points and it's sad! I liked the adventure of the book, but there were too many characters that were pointless imo. I'm like who is this and where did he/she come from. I totally get not keeping just the same ppl that the series started with but there were too many introduction at once? Idk maybe it's for the next books? Maybe they could have been mentioned a tad more previously in that case.
For the ending, I did ask myself if we were really ending on that note (right after battle, same ending) Is it terrible? No, not imo. Could have been better? Absolutely. I was expecting way more, after reading the first 2. I'm hoping this series gets right back on track with how great books 1 and 2 are.
However, I feel everyone has their own opinion just like with anything else. I plan to start the series over and see if it's better the 2nd time. (To see if onyx storm is better that is. I already know I love the first 2.) HAPPY READING, STAY KIND 🩷