I feel like True Detective was almost a spiritual successor in a a sense but more mashed with a touch of the movie Seven as it had far less of a Kolchak feel for much of it. That last season went in a wild direction with the alien ice thing felt like a spinoff in itself.
If they are doing something completely new as has been reported they could really be successful in doing something similar but bringing back some of the key elements, supernatural/paranormal from the earlier episodes, regional lore (big foot, neanderthal, red devil, etc,), maybe even werewolf or changelings, and yes of course aliens.