Matthew
#YM099017
Follow
Followed
Following:
0
Topics
0
Users
Reviews
0
Ratings
1
My Posts(14)
10-Part Dystopian Miniseries On HBO Is A Rare Show Where Every Episode Is Great
Station Eleven is such a great book that it shocked me that the miniseries was able to make such huge departures from the source material that made the story better at the same time.
Disney+’s $1.5B Space Opera Soaring Past Marvel Classics As A Streaming Hit
Lamaj Really? And what would you call memorable or otherwise outstanding about the characters and plots?
10 Smartest Characters In Star Trek History, Ranked
Balok and Trelane (or, more specifically, Trelane's parents) are smarter than most or all of these. Also the Guardians of Forever, Talosians, and Metrons.
John Carpenter's 1980s Sci-Fi Officially Returns, Finally Completing the Trilogy (Exclusive)
Two things: First, this movie did not help launch Kurt Russell's career. He had been a star for two decades by then. What you mean to say is this was one of his first R rated films (but not even the first that).
Second, while Watergate may have been one of Carpeter's early inspirations on the script (given when it was written) the public consciousness had largely moved on by 1981.
The far bigger influence was the public's response to out of control crime. The dystopia urban crime genera (Death Wish, Dirty Harry, Taxi Driver) became a thing in that era, along with even more, societal collapse by crime, dystopian takes like Mad Max and The Warriors.
The landslide election of Ronald Reagan was a direct response to the general feeling that governments had failed the people on crime. And, like the others, this film was a warning about where that was headed. If people were still freaking out about Watergate, they would have reelected Carter.
Snow White’s $169 Million Disappointment May Be The Tipping Point For Disney’s Live-Action Remakes
Failing to even acknowledge that a significant percentage of those who stayed away did so because of politics is borderline cowardice.
Star Trek 4 Is The Perfect Opportunity To Make Up For A 16-Year-Old William Shatner Disappointment
Want to bring him back, just so he can make a cameo? Have Pine's Kirk discover a holo log he left to himself, to be opened at this particular time and date.
Problem solved.
“Nero Fiddling While Rome Burns”: Stephen King Doubles Down On 2025 Oscars Cancellation Call After Hearing From Ceremony Supporters
I honestly had not been aware that King had ever attended an Oscars ceremony before.
Some how I imagine they'll muddle through without them.
15 Best Movies Based On A True Story
Except for "Schindler's List" and "Oppenheimer," "Lawrence of Arabia" is better than the other 13 films here put together.
5 Fantasy Movie Villains So Powerful They Should've Been Unstoppable, But Got Beat Anyway
You forgot the Evil One from "Time Bandits"
The Chronicles Of Narnia: What Happens To Susan Pevensie In The Last Battle
You people keep writing different versions of the same story. Susan's absence in The Last Battle has exactly zero to do with "sexism." Please make an effort to actually read the books if you are going to continue to write articles.
Several characters, both male and female "age out" and are kept out of Narnia throughout the story, including Digroy, Polly, and even Peter, the High King. Peter is also kept out of Narnia in "The Voyage of the Dawn Treader" because, like Susan, he has grown up enough that he begins to think that Narnia was just a childhood fantasy.
Lewis originally wrote these books for his niece, Lucy Barfield, and Narnia is a metaphore for faith.
By the time of "The Last Battle," Lucy is about or close to 18, which is an adult by post WW2 standards. Also present in Narnia are Jill Pole, who is about 20, and Aunt Polly, who is MUCH older. So we have three adult females, and four adult males that return to Narnia just as that world is ending.
Lewis wanted to write a story about faith, and he needed a character who loses hers. He picked Susan, and he lays the groundwork for this all the way back in "The Lion the Witch and the Wardrobe," and then returns to that theme in both "Prince Caspian" and Dawn Treader. However, it is made clear that there is still a place for Susan in Narnia if she ever manages to get her faith back.
You keep inserting controversy where none exists because it is that important to you that there is a place in this story for Saoirse Ronan that you would have Gerwig completely change the story. There IS a place for her. She's old enough now to play Jadis or the Lady of the Green Veil. Leave Susan alone. She's perfectly imperfect exactly as Lewis created her.
The Chronicles Of Narnia Franchise Needs A Movie That Breaks The Books' Biggest Rule
Screenrant, you are getting much closer to understanding what is going on with Susan's absence in The Last Battle. Lucy, Edmund and Peter are there because they have all died in this world and Aslan's new kingdom is a version of the afterlife.
In this world they had gone to the train station to pick up Professor Kirke, Aunt Polly, Eustace Scrubb and Jill Pole. Lucy and her siblings (except Susan) were waiting to meet up with them when the train crashed at the station. Together these people all refer to themselves as "The Friends of Narnia." Presumably they have been summoned together for this moment.
Lucy is about 17 or 18. We know from the Silver Chair that Jill is a couple of years older than Lucy. So, by post WW2 standards we have 3 adult females returning to Narnia, and one who does not.
Please stop introducing sexism as the reason why Lewis shut Susan out of Narnia (at the time of the book). He wanted to introduce one character who had reasoned himself or herself away from faith, and because Lucy is the main character her older sister makes the most sense for that character arc. But, as you mentioned, Lewis definitely does leave the door open for Susan to join the others.
Try writing a column about that.
Greta Gerwig's Narnia Remake Could Solve A Big Susan Pevensie Problem With A Popular Casting Choice
This is absurd. Susan is portrayed as abandoning childlike wonder in favor of more adult and worldly interests. The books are written for children, and say nothing at all about sexuality. Furthermore, as they are also a metaphor for religious faith, Susan is really a model for all of us as results. And, it should be noted, it the books specifically leave the door open for Susan to return to Narnia at some point in the future -specifically through the character arc of of Eustace.
The Chronicles Of Narnia's Best Redemption Story Should Have Set Up A Different Ending
Susan wasn't "punished" by Aslan. She chose to favor status in the real world over the paradise Alsan offers her. The books make it clear that this is a very conscious decision on her part. She dismisses her siblings when they try to talk to her about it.
There's no getting around the fact that these are deeply Christian books, and these are common Christian themes.
That being said, Aslan leaves the door open for Susan to return to Him, but He's not going to force it on her. It's her choice. Not all people who choose Door #2 are inherently evil. That's Lewis's point.
Invent a new character arc for her would entirely defeat the purpose of remaining the Narnia in it. Might as well include Optimus Prime in it at that point.