With the newest Scream hitting theaters on January 14, 2022, it's got fans reminiscing what drew them into Sidney Prescott and the Woodsboro Murders in the first place. What is it about these characters and their storylines that have kept audiences coming back? Was it seeing characters they loved and trusted be revealed as the killer(s)? Was it watching a side character rise into unexpected heroism?
It may have something to do with the way the Scream franchise twists and turns the plot and is best known for making it near impossible to guess who's behind it all. After all, finding out who the killer is often changes the story entirely, as well as who Sidney ends up with or even trusts in the next film.
An Illegitimate Child
In Scream 5, fans were shocked to learn that one of the main characters, Sam Carpenter, is the daughter of the original killer, Billy Loomis. Though somewhat abrupt, as it was never alluded to in the first Scream, this adds a whole new layer to the storyline.
Sam is seen as a protective older sister who wants to rekindle their estranged relationship. She's likable, sympathetic, and fans can relate to the regret she seems to harbor. However, finding out she is the daughter of a serial killer adds complexity to her character. Did she inherit her father's dark side? It adds tension and leads fans to wonder if she's behind the most recent slayings.
Full Circle
In Scream 5, it isn't until Sidney puts a tracker on Sam's car and follows her location that the audience learns Amber lives in what used to be Stu Macher's house, one of the killers in the original movie.
Once Sidney realizes whose house it is, it makes sense that the final showdown would take place here. It adds to the drama that has haunted Sidney all her life. By defeating the killer once and for all in the house where it all started, it also allows her an even greater sense of closure. The many rumors and predictions about Scream 6 also leave fans wondering if more locations from earlier movies may pop up again.
The Narrator
Randy won over audiences with his nerdy charm and comic relief, but his ability to foresee the plot just before it happens cannot go unmentioned either.
This was an interesting and original element to add to a horror franchise. It could easily have ruined the films' unpredictability, leaving a blueprint of what happens next. But instead, it pokes at the fourth wall, winks at the audience, adding to the unpredictability, rather than taking away from it.
The Hero Is Still Alive
After Jill stabs her cousin Sidney in Scream 4, fans were unsure how the movie would wrap up. When Dewey visits Jill in the hospital, he tells her that Sidney is in the ICU, fighting for her life, that there's a chance she'll survive. At that moment, fans knew Sidney would be the one to finish the job.
Because this movie came out eleven years after Scream 3, it seemed possible that Sidney might die in Scream 4. However, her still hanging on proves what fans have known and enjoyed seeing in her all along: that she's a fighter. Of course, her survival always means her story isn't over, leaving room for another killer to come along and finish what was started.
The Other Woman
At the beginning of the first Scream, fans learn that Billy's mother left his father, but the reason for her leaving isn't explicit until he admits to being one of the killers. There always has to be a good motive, and Billy feels justified in his: Sidney's mother had an affair with Billy's father, causing his family to split.
This was important for Billy's story because while the audience disagrees with his idea of revenge, they're able to understand him more and see him as a son deeply hurt by his mother's absence.
Like Mother, Like Son
At the end of Scream 2, when Mickey takes off his Ghostface mask, it's as confusing, as it is a bit of a letdown. What avenge-seeking role does he take in this? Minutes later, the second and true killer is revealed as Billy's mother, Deb, and fans get the satisfying motive they crave.
This can almost be seen as double revenge: the revenge of her son and the revenge for herself -- the woman scorned. It answers the question of what happened to Billy's mother after she left, which may have felt open-ended to some in the first movie. It also gives Sidney the chance to face a person she may have once felt sorry for and a demon she struggles with: her mother wasn't who she thought she was.
It's Always Who You Least Suspect
In Scream 4, fans were shocked to see Sidney's own cousin Jill and her classmate, cinema club guru Charlie as Woodsboro's newest killers. Jill explains what it was like to grow up in Sidney's shadow and claims that now it's her turn for fame.
This film may have been the one to solidify to the audience that Sidney will never outrun this. What's satisfying is fans get to watch her notice this herself, recognize that it's inevitable, and therefore use it as a strength. A sort of weapon. It also adds to the believability of her self-isolation. If one of her own family is willing to kill her, then who can she really trust?
The Lone Survivor
It wasn't enough for Jill to be one of the survivors of the new and even more gruesome Woodsboro Murders: she had to be the only one. Her craving for fame led her to murder her partner in crime.
Scream 4 really leaned into the "remake" aspect -- the idea that everything has to be gorier, darker, stakes higher. While Jill's killing Charlie mimics Deb killing her partner Mickey in Scream 2, the reason for doing so is entirely different. One wants to cut to the chase, get down to what she went there to do. The other is to achieve a life of the rich and famous. Scream 4 either emphasized that there really doesn't need to be a classic "revenge-seeking" motive or changed the idea of motive completely. Call the culprit psychotic, call them deranged, this twist upped the ante in the "who is killing and why" factor.
The Half-Brother She Never Knew
Scream 3 throws one of the biggest curveballs by abiding by what the audience comes to know as "trilogy rules," meaning all bets are off. Fans learn that Sidney's late mother, Maureen, lived an off-the-record life in Hollywood for a few years and was even an actress. In the final showdown, Roman, Stab 3's director reveals himself to not only be Ghostface but also Sidney's half brother, Maureen Prescott's true killer, and the orchestrator of the entire plot -- to avenge the mother that never wanted him.
This was crucial for Sidney's storyline because she still struggles with the realization that she didn't know her mother as much as she thought she did. With this plot twist, fans get to watch her let go of that struggle and find comfort in the fact that she never will. The third movie was all about closure and moving forward. Putting the emphasis on moving forward without having all the answers makes this scene even more relatable.
The Original "Not One, But Two"
It came as shock to fans when Sidney Prescott's beloved boyfriend, Billy, turned out to be Ghostface, but fans were doubly shocked to learn Stu was also in on it. A duo of killers?
Fans cared that it was Billy and Stu for a few reasons. One is that these were friends she's known and trusted. Another is that the audience grew to trust Billy along with Sidney. They began to see him as the good, protective boyfriend, unjustly being pinned for murder. Another more subtle reason that fans cared is much more pertinent to the franchise as a whole. This kind of guessing, right up until the end, was the blueprint for each film and one of the elements that's driven the franchise's success. Fans come into each movie expecting another game of "whodunit."