The following contains brief descriptions of the plot of Shelby Oaks, which contains sexual assault in the plot.
The following contains spoilers for Shelby OaksShelby Oaks is a tragic horror film that doesn't relent in its somber tone once Riley Brennan's fate has been revealed. Directed and written by Chris Stuckmann, Shelby Oaks is a medley of genre conventions and influences focused on the disappearance of a young paranormal investigator and her sister's efforts to find her.
The film's ability to hop between styles is commendable, especially as it unravels more of the mystery and what exactly happened to Riley Brennan. However, it takes some unexpectedly heavy turns amid all the genre fare, building to a brutal climax that recalls the history of the horror genre as a whole.
What Happened To Riley Brennan?
The mystery surrounding Riley Brennan is at the core of Shelby Oaks, but the film takes an even darker turn after she's found. Riley is quickly established by an in-universe documentary to have gained notoriety when she and her co-stars in the Paranormal Paranoids, a YouTube paranormal investigative team, went missing in Shelby Oaks.
While the others were killed, Riley's fate was a mystery until Wilson Miles took his own life in front of Riley's sister Mia. Mia followed the trail from Miles to Riley, eventually finding her held prisoner in the home of Wilson's mother Norma. Norma is revealed to have been serving some demonic entity, with Wilson is controlled by it.
As this plot runs through Shelby Oaks, there's also the steady reflection from Mia that Riley was seemingly haunted by a demonic imaginary friend in their youth. Seeing signs of the entity again in the present day (including a pack of hellhounds) and eventually admitting she also once saw it, this connection turns out to be why Riley was kidnapped.
Norma kept Riley and Wilson in her dungeon-like home and forced her son to repeatedly sexually assault Riley until a baby was born. While the full circumstances and intentions of the birth aren't revealed, the demon imagery and ritualistic items in Norma's room suggest they were crucial to the demon's plans for Riley and the infant.
Saving Riley and the child, Mia is horrified when Riley later tries to suffocate her infant son. This leads to a struggle where Riley is pushed out a window and mauled to death by the hellhounds. It's a brutal ending for Riley, with little in the way of mitigating the sheer brutality of the situation.
It's left ambiguous what made Riley special to Tario, only adding to the underlying terror by suggesting a certain degree of randomness or unknown destiny to the narrative. Ultimately, the movie isn't really about Riley, who primarily serves as backstory and motivation for Mia's investigation.
Why Mia Saves Riley's Son
Mia's efforts to find Riley dominate much of the film, with the obvious cost of her marriage to Robert and eventually the life of her sister. However, her decision to save the baby at the cost of Riley's life also pays off a desire of the character earlier in the film: a child of her own.
Despite their efforts, the film's in-universe documentary establishes that Mia and Robert tried to have a baby but couldn't conceive. The lingering sadness over this — as evidenced by the empty crib in their home — hints that their marital stress extends far beyond Mia's search for Riley. Her claims of demons just prove to be the final straw for Robert.
While she may have saved the seemingly innocent baby, the film's hints about the demonic force working behind the scenes suggest this is exactly what the entity wanted all along. Known as Tario, the demon is revealed to have wanted a mortal child and has now ensured it has a new guardian who always wanted a baby of their own.
It's a grim turn for Mia, who ends the film screaming as Tario embraces her as his new vassal. This could set her up to become like Norma, a corrupted mother willing to sacrifice her own family for the sake of the demon's commands. Norma's disappearance leaves this beat purposefully ambiguous, adding a frightening layer of mystery to the demon's intentions.
The True Meaning Of Shelby Oaks
Shelby Oaks is a grim film, with a willingness to embrace a bleak storyline and tragedy for its main characters. In many ways, the film builds on the legacy of other scary movies like Rosemary's Baby and The Omen, which also involved demonic entities targeting children. In those films, the demonic entity is also ultimately victorious.
There's an undercurrent of social expectation and commentary in Stuckmann's approach to the horror tropes. The media circus that erupts around Riley eventually dies down, accepting her just as another missing person's case. She mattered to the general public almost as little as she mattered to the demon, both accepting her demise offhandedly.
Similar to the subtext in Rosemary's Baby about a young woman forced to embrace a domestic life she didn't want, being filtered through the lens of horror, Shelby Oaks highlights how women like Riley and Mia can be used in the designs of others (as a mother, a wife, a tool, a servant) without any concern for their own agency.
In the end, neither woman could gain their own freedom, whether that be from the expectations of a heartbroken husband or the demonic force that's been haunting them their entire lives. It's a grim finale for both characters, with the ending of Shelby Oaks giving Tario the ultimate victory.
Shelby Oaks
- Release Date
- October 2, 2025
- Runtime
- 99 minutes
- Director
- chris stuckmann
- Writers
- Chris Stuckmann, Sam Liz
Cast
-
Morton Jacobson -
Sarah DurnRiley
Your comment has not been saved