Sherlock and Elementary may have the same premise, but the shows are different enough for fans of Arthur Conan Doyle’s character to watch both without worrying about comparisons. CBS’s Elementary premiered in 2012, two years after BBC’s Sherlock debuted. Between the Robert Downey Jr.-led Sherlock movies and the BBC show, Sherlock Holmes was experiencing a popularity resurgence in the early 2010s that made an American show all but inevitable. Still, given that Elementary would also be about a contemporary version of the character, comparisons between the CBS show and the Benedict Cumberbatch one quickly dominated the conversation.

Jonny Lee Miller played a very different contemporary Sherlock Holmes from Benedict Cumberbatch, and that was only one of many differences between the CBS procedural and the BBC show. However, considering that Elementary came out when Sherlock was at its peak – both in terms of popularity and quality – the American show would often be unfairly compared to the British one. Elementary was not trying to hit the same notes as Sherlock, which is why watching both series makes for very distinct experiences.

Elementary’s Procedural Formula Makes It Completely Different From Sherlock

Elementary Had More Than 20 Murders For Sherlock To Solve Per Season

While both Sherlock and Elementary saw Holmes working on a different case every episode, the structure of the CBS show could not have been more different from the BBC one. As an American network television series, Elementary usually had 24 episodes per season. It ran for seven seasons and concluded its run at 154 episodes. BBC’s Sherlock, on the other hand, had 12 episodes in total and a special. Another big difference was the length of said episodes – each Sherlock episode was 90 minutes long, whereas Elementary's episodes were 44 minutes long.

Show

First Episode

Final Episode

Rotten Tomatoes Critic Score

Rotten Tomatoes Audience Score

Sherlock

July 25, 2010

January 25, 2017

78%

83%

Elementary

September 27, 2012

August 15, 2019

95%

89%

Elementary was a more traditional procedural whose structure was not that different from most American crime shows, the only catch being that Sherlock Holmes was now involved. Elementary included all of the tropes you would expect from a CSI or Law & Order episode, yet it never felt too generic thanks to the character of Sherlock Holmes. This was a different approach from BBC’s Sherlock, where each episode felt like a chapter of a larger story. The cases in BBC’s Sherlock felt bigger and more interconnected than the ones in Elementary.

Elementary And Sherlock Aren’t Really Similar (Despite Having The Same Premise)

Sherlock And Elementary Share Little Other Than Their Main Character

Benedict Cumberbatch and Jonny Lee Miller as Sherlock Holmes in Sherlock and Elementary
Benedict Cumberbatch and Jonny Lee Miller as Sherlock Holmes in Sherlock and Elementary

It’s easy to compare Sherlock and Elementary given that they share the same premise – a contemporary version of Sherlock Holmes’ mythos. However, there are so many differences between the shows that is arguably unfair to compare them. Sherlock had a unique charm that would be impossible to replicate in a show with 24 episodes per season, just like Elementary’s hundreds of cases of the week offered something one would never get from the BBC show.

When Elementary was announced, there was some controversy surrounding the CBS series' similarities to BBC’s Sherlock that almost evolved into a legal battle. Back in 2012, Sherlock producer Sue Vertue revealed that CBS had approached them to remake the British show, which did not happen (via The Independent). To The Hollywood Reporter, CBS explained that Elementary was going to be based on Sherlock Holmes and related characters, not the BBC show. Interestingly, Elementary outlived Sherlock, with the former ending two years after the latter.

Source: The Independent, The Hollywood Reporter.

  • 7wtsnhkba0fag6r9twffde0i9hl.jpg
    131
    9.3/10
    7/10

    Sherlock

    Release Date
    2010 - 2017-00-00
    Network
    BBC One
    Showrunner
    Steven Moffat
    Directors
    Paul McGuigan, Nick Hurran, Euros Lyn, Jeremy Lovering, Rachel Talalay, Colm McCarthy, Toby Haynes
    Writers
    Steve Thompson
    Franchise(s)
    Sherlock Holmes


    This adaptation Sherlock and Watson as they establish their partnership and begin solving strange mysteries throughout the U.K. and beyond. Set in a more 2010's modern setting, Sherlock's eccentric and complex nature is accentuated as he solves seemingly supernatural crimes with unparalleled intellect while struggling to connect with others on a human level. Meanwhile, Watson blogs the stories summarizing their cases while building a strained but caring friendship with his new partner.

    Seasons
    4
    Streaming Service(s)
    Dis, Netflix
  • 0337124_poster_w780.jpg
    88
    9.4/10
    8/10

    Elementary

    Release Date
    2012 - 2019-00-00
    Network
    CBS
    Directors
    Guy Ferland, John Polson, Christine Moore, Seith Mann, Jerry Levine, Lucy Liu, Larry Teng, Aaron Lipstadt, Andrew Bernstein, Michael Slovis, Sanaa Hamri, Alex Chapple, Michael Pressman, Jennifer Lynch, John David Coles, Jonny Lee Miller, Peter Werner, Jeremy Webb, Adam Davidson, Aidan Quinn, Colin Bucksey, Craig Zisk, David Platt, Helen Shaver
    Writers
    Robert Hewitt Wolfe, Tamara Jaron, Kelly Wheeler, Jordan Rosenberg, Arika Lisanne Mittman, Peter Ocko, Mark Hudis, Nick Thiel, Brian Rodenbeck, Cathryn Humphris, Paul Cornell, Richard C. Okie, Christopher Hollier, Andrew Gettens, Lauren MacKenzie
    Elementary Joan Watson (Lucy Liu) and Sherlock Holmes (Jonny Lee Miller) sitting next to one another.
    • Headshot Of Jonny Lee Miller
      Jonny Lee Miller
      Sherlock Holmes
    • Headshot Of Lucy Liu
      Lucy Liu
      Joan Watson

    A modern retelling of Arthur Conan Doyle's Sherlock Holmes stories, Elementary is set in New York City and details the adventures of Dr. Joan Watson (Lucy Liu) who becomes partner to the consulting detective Sherlock Holmes (Johnny Lee Miller) after first being assigned as his sober companion. Set up a procedural crime drama, the series includes multiple references to the original Holmes stories, often with surprising twists.

    Seasons
    7
    Streaming Service(s)
    Hulu