Content Warning: This article discusses sexual assault and suicide.

While The Simpsons isn’t known for its dark humor, occasionally the family sitcom can get away with some seriously un-family-friendly gags. The Simpsons is not as edgy, profane, or dark as its competitors South Park, Family Guy, and American Dad. The iconic long-running animated sitcom relies on shock humor less than its imitators, with The Simpsons cultivating a more family-friendly image than the shows that followed its success. However, this doesn’t mean that The Simpsons is afraid of dark humor, and, particularly in its early seasons, the show could be shockingly cynical at times.

While The Simpsons season 34 changed the show’s formula from time to time, like most recent outings of the series, its humor is fairly reliably tame. The Simpsons largely dropped its bleak world from around season 3 onwards, replacing darker punchlines with a larger number of jokes and more cartoony, zany humor. In the show’s so-called Golden Age (roughly seasons 3-12), The Simpsons developed a unique style that blended character comedy with cartoony sight gags, wordplay, slapstick, and some black humor. In this era, the darkest jokes in The Simpsons were mostly throwaway gags, and the show has maintained this approach since. That said, there were still some dark moments.

10 Homer Vs Dignity's Zenith

Homer sits next to Mr. Burns dressed as Santa Claus in The Simpsons

Typically, the darkest jokes in The Simpsons are brief moments that fans might miss on first viewing. This allows The Simpsons to avoid getting in hot water with censors but also ensures the show never gets too dark for too long. However, The Simpsons season 12, episode 5, “Homer vs. Dignity,” abandoned this approach with an uncomfortably lengthy scene wherein Homer is sexually assaulted by a panda while dressed as a panda. It’s a rare moment of pure shock humor from the usually family-friendly show and, perhaps not coincidentally, the episode aired shortly after South Park become an undeniable cultural juggernaut and massive merchandising machine in 2000.

9 She Shouldn’t Have Mouthed Off Like That

Marge and Homer Simpson in an episode of The Simpsons.

While Homer treats Marge’s mother well in The Simpsons, he hasn’t always been so kind toward the elderly. In The Simpsons season 5, episode 11, “Homer the Vigilante,” Homer starts a militia intended to curb crime and almost immediately becomes a corrupt thug. At one point, Homer recounts a story to his fellow gang members, saying “So I said to him, Listen, buddy, your car was upside-down when we got here. And as for your grandmother, she shouldn’t have mouthed off like that.” It’s clear that Homer at least mistreated an elderly woman, but Medium writer Mark Dellandre noted that these details also hint at a literary allusion that implies Homer killed her.

8 Adil’s Got A Point

The Simpson family sit in front of the TV from season 1
The Simpson family sit in front of the TV from season 1

In The Simpsons season 1, episode 11, “The Crepes of Wrath,” Bart ends up enslaved by French winemakers when he takes part in a foreign exchange program. As noted above, the early seasons of The Simpsons are uncharacteristically dark, but Bart’s plot isn’t home to this episode’s bleakest gag. Instead, Homer’s attempts to break up an argument between Lisa and an Albanian exchange student, Adil, are what really sting. Per Homer, “Maybe Lisa’s right about America being the land of opportunity, and maybe Adil has a point about the machinery of capitalism being oiled with the blood of the workers.” Notably, Adil’s surname (Hoxha) is borrowed from a famous Communist leader.

7 Moe’s Lost Love

Moe answers Bart's prank call in The Simpsons

While the eponymous family has been through a lot across the show’s 34 seasons, it is the obscure supporting characters of The Simpsons that often suffer the show’s cruelest fates. After all, The Simpsons needs Bart, Lisa, Marge, Maggie, and Homer to be alright by the end of each episode, but the show can write off one-note characters for the sake of a mean gag. This became clear during one brutal cutaway gag in The Simpsons season 22, epidote 13, “The Blue and the Gray,” which sees Moe optimistically claim there’s a woman for every man on earth, only for The Simpsons to cut to his ideal match hanging herself.

6 The First Female Stealth Bomber Pilot

Sideshow Bob holds Bart and Lisa over a dam in The Simpsons

In The Simpsons season 7, episode 9, “Sideshow Bob’s Last Gleaming,” the entire Simpson clan is looking forward to the Springfield Air Show. This makes sense for Bart and Homer, but it was harder for the writers to justify the bookish intellectual Lisa’s interest. The episode got around this with Lisa enthusiastically exclaiming that she wanted to meet the first female stealth bomber pilot since “during the Gulf War, she destroyed 70 mosques, and her name is Lisa too!”

5 The Running You Over Prank

The Simpsons - Homer Goes To College

While later seasons of The Simpsons questioned Homer’s reliability as a narrator, earlier outings of the show mined a lot of humor from the disparity between his expectations and reality. This is the central gag in The Simpsons season 5, episode 3, “Homer Goes To College,” wherein he insists that his experience of higher learning should resemble a classic ‘80s college comedy filled with hijinks and lowbrow antics. This plot culminates in Homer running over the accommodating, amenable college dean and leaving him in a full-body cast as a “prank.”

4 Lisa’s Richie Rich Theory

Comic Book Guy in his store in The Simpsons

In The Simpsons season 2, episode 21, “Three Men and a Comic Book,” Milhouse, Martin Prince, and Bart come to blows over a valuable comic book they purchase together. Before that battle, however, comes the outing’s grimmest gag. After Bart and Lisa purchase some comics, Bart notes that Casper the Friendly Ghost looks like Richie Rich. In response, Lisa speculates that Richie Rich (who is a small child) might have committed suicide after realizing the pursuit of money was pointless.

3 Chief Wiggum’s Law Advice

Chief Wiggum holds a plice baton in Simpsons

In The Simpsons season 11, episode 21, “It's a Mad, Mad, Mad, Mad Marge,” Marge attempts to convince her family that Otto’s seemingly sweet former fiancée Becky is secretly attempting to usurp her and steal her family. The Simpson clan is unmoved, so Marge asks the police to help, only to be informed that they can’t help her. Later, Chief Wiggum clarifies to Marge that the law is “powerless to help you, not to punish you,” while carting her away for a crime she didn’t commit.

2 Why They Call Her Miss Hoover

Sad Future Bart Simpson in Holidays of Future Past

The many future-set episodes of The Simpsons feature different, often contradictory versions of the titular family’s fates. However, The Simpsons season 25, episode 18, “Days of Future Future” features one fate fans will likely want to retcon. Since it is a future-set episode, everyone is over the age of consent, but Bart boasting about his childhood schoolteacher’s oral sex skills is still a grim gag. Admittedly, a cutaway punchline shows that Miss Hoover was literally vacuuming, but "now I see why they call you Miss Hoover" is still a discomforting joke.

1 Everything in “Homer’s Enemy”

Simpsons Frank GRimes

In The Simpsons season 8, episode 23, “Homer’s Enemy,” Homer gets a new co-worker named Frank Grimes. A studious, industrious man, Grimes can’t believe how successful Homer’s life has been despite the character’s incompetence and laziness. This eventually drives Grimes to madness, leading him to accidentally kill himself, only for Homer to loudly snore at his funeral to the delight of his charmed colleagues. Often listed as one of the best episodes of The Simpsons, the entire plot of “Homer’s Enemy” also has the dubious distinction of being the show’s longest, darkest joke ever.

Source: Medium