Summary

  • Sitcom plot twists can be unexpected and surprising, even though comedy is their main focus.
  • Not all plot twists in sitcoms are lighthearted, as they can include darker themes such as death and affairs.
  • Sometimes sitcoms throw off their audience by introducing unexpected plot twists, like sudden pregnancies or characters coming back to life.

While a TV sitcom's main purpose is not to shock or surprise audiences with plot twists, there have been some completely unexpected moments in the sitcom format. A big shock in any television show is often foreshadowed, although this isn't exclusively, and when it isn't, it makes the moment even more surprising. Even in between laughs and giggles, sitcoms still have the power to completely throw off an audience.

It's worth noting that even in comedies, their plot twists aren't always light-hearted. Sitcoms have had their darker moments, even if they are underplayed with humor. Whether it is a death, an affair, new loves, pregnancies, or anything in between, there have been many big plot twists in sitcoms.

15 Leslie Gets Pregnant With Triplets

Parks And Recreation

Leslie and Ben finding out they're expecting triplets in the episode One in 8000
Leslie and Ben finding out they're expecting triplets in the episode One in 8000

Despite appearing to be the busiest woman in the world, in Parks and Recreation season 6, Leslie (Amy Poehler) discovers that she's pregnant with her husband Ben's (Adam Scott) baby. In one of Ben and Leslie's most important episodes, Leslie believes she's caught an awful case of the flu, but instead finds out that her family is growing. However, it didn't stop there, as in the very next episode the couple are told that they are expecting triplets. A sudden pregnancy is not an unusual concept in sitcoms, but the upcoming arrival of triplets is unheard of.

14 Michael's Death

Jane the Virgin

Michael Cordero's death in the Jane the Virgin episode Chapter 54
Michael Cordero's death in the Jane the Virgin episode Chapter 54
Jane the Virgin

Release Date
October 13, 2014
Seasons
5

Despite being one of Jane the Virgin's most crucial characters, Michael Cordero (Brett Dier) was rather suddenly killed off in the episode "Chapter Fifty-Four." His death was particularly surprising as it happened at the end of the episode with no foreshadowing, and he had also already survived near death just a few episodes before. After these events, Jane the Virgin had a three-year time jump, and over time, Jane (Gina Rodriguez) entered a relationship with Mateo's father, Rafael (Justin Baldoni).

The show then lured audiences into a false sense of security. All loved up and a happy family, Jane believed that Rafael was going to propose, but he instead revealed that Michael was, in fact, still alive. Not only was Michael's death unexpected, but to watch Jane move on and then find out her husband wasn't really dead was just heartbreaking.

13 Clare's Father Dies

Derry Girls

Clare after saying goodbye to her father as he died in Derry Girls season 3
Clare after saying goodbye to her father as he died in Derry Girls season 3
Derry Girls
  • Cast Placeholder Image
    Saoirse-Monica Jackson
  • Cast Placeholder Image
    Louisa Harland

Release Date
January 4, 2018
Seasons
3

Even though Derry Girls was set during the Troubles in Ireland in the 1990s, which brought an expectation of possible casualties, the loss of Clare's (Nicola Coughlan) father was still a huge plot twist. Despite Sean (David Ireland) dying from an aneurysm, rather than anything related to the ongoing violence at the time, it was still completely unexpected, especially as it happened at the end of a rather normal episode. What made the Derry Girls season 3 death even more gutting was Gerry (Tommy Tiernan) having to announce the news to the kids, crushing Clare, who moments before had experienced her first kiss.

12 Brian Griffin Is Hit By A Car

Family Guy

Family Guy
  • Headshot OF Seth MacFarlane
    Seth MacFarlane
  • Headshot Of Alex Borstein
    Alex Borstein
  • Headshot Of Seth Green
  • Headshot Of Mila Kunis
    Mila Kunis

Release Date
January 31, 1999
Seasons
24

An unexpected moment in Family Guy that was thankfully rectified was the death of the Griffin's dog, Brian (Seth McFarlane). In a shocking twist of events, while playing with Stewie (McFarlane) in the street, Brian was hit by a car. While Family Guy typically downplays dark moments as being run-of-the-mill situations with humor, this was one occasion in which the show was incredibly emotional and moving. Luckily, he was able to come back to life just two episodes later after Stewie went back in time, but it was still a moment that nobody could have seen coming.

11 Penny's Pregnancy

The Big Bang Theory

Penny and Leonard happily talking about their pregnancy in secret during TBBT finale
Penny and Leonard happily talking about their pregnancy in secret during TBBT finale

Release Date
September 24, 2007
Seasons
12

In The Big Bang Theory, Penny (Kaley Cuoco) often voiced that she didn't have any interest in having kids. However, in the show's finale, Penny and Leonard (Johnny Galecki) announced that they were expecting. Although some of the later episodes from season 12 saw Penny slowly start to reconsider her decision, it was never fully addressed. Her conversations with her father started to turn Penny's head on the topic, but even so, such a big life decision is not something that happens overnight. So, when she and Leonard announced their pregnancy after being quiet about potentially having children for a while, it was quite the plot twist.

10 Dan Conner Had Died

Roseanne

Roseanne sits at her desk writing in the Roseanne season 9 episode "Into That Good Night."
Roseanne writing in Roseanne season 9
Roseanne

Release Date
October 18, 1988
Seasons
10

The sitcom Roseanne is remembered for its season 10 retcon, although given how season 9 ended, it was probably for the best. Roseanne spent an entire season focusing on The Conners' lives after winning the lottery, as well as audiences watching Roseanne (Barr) dealing with Dan's (John Goodman) infidelity. However, its final episode revealed that all of these events were simply a figment of the titular character's imagination.

In reality, Dan had died at the end of season 8, and the Conners didn't win the lottery. Although it's not uncommon to see the whole "it was all a dream" trope on television, Dan's death was especially shocking in this context, as usually the cover-up for reality is overly positive. However, Roseanne's way of coping with her grief was to imagine he'd cheated on her instead, which was simply stunning. When the show came back for season 10 after being off the air for eleven years, Dan was suddenly alive again, and the entire affair was retconned.

9 The Monkey Stole Annie's Pen

Community

A pile of Annie's stolen pens in Community
A pile of Annie's stolen pens in Community

One of Community's best episodes made use of a singular setting, as the gang spiraled into chaos over Annie's (Alison Brie) missing pen. "Cooperative Calligraphy" is a great example of a TV bottle episode, as well as an overall study of the Community characters, as they all turned against each other. Each member of the group's denial is not only hilarious, but with each one, complicates the story further, and the true identity of the thief slips further away with each minute.

The end of the episode reveals that the pen thief was actually Annie's Boobs, Troy's (Donald Glover) monkey. The animal was first introduced in the season 1 episode "Contemporary American Poultry" but hadn't been seen again until this moment. Not only was this a huge plot twist because of the return of the forgotten monkey, but also because, after a deep, psychological argument between the group had broken out, the true thief's identity was simply ridiculous.

8 Erin Finds Her Birth Parents

The Office

Erin and her birth parents watching Dwight and Angela's wedding in The Office finale.
Erin and her parents in The Office finale 
Deedle-Dee Productions

Release Date
March 24, 2005
Seasons
9

Since her introduction in The Office, one of Erin's (Ellie Kemper) most memorable details surrounded her growing up in foster care. Erin often spoke about finding her birth parents one day, and at one point, even took a DNA test to see if she was the child that Phyllis (Phyllis Smith) had given up years previously. Although it seemed like there was no hope for the Dunder Mifflin secretary to reunite with her birth family, the storyline was unexpectedly resolved in The Office finale, when the couple arrived at the meet and greet.

While the reunification was rather sweet and wholesome, it was still a big plot twist for the show. After years of waiting, it was unexpected for Erin to not only find her parents, but to find that the two were still together and wanted to be a part of her life. It was lovely to see Erin get a happy ending, and considering she wasn't one of the main characters in The Office, it was great to see her story get some closure that wasn't related to her romantic relationships.

7 The Identity Of The Ass Crack Bandit

Community

Annie stands in the rain with a hooded coat in Community season 5.
Annie stands in the rain with a hooded coat in Community season 5.

A recurring storyline throughout Community revolved around the Ass Crack Bandit, a mysterious serial prankster who would drop coins down students' trousers at unexpected moments. Despite the satirical element, Greendale Community College treated the figure like a hardcore criminal, with Annie in particular determined to find out their identity. In season 5, after a year with no incidents, the Bandit struck again, and Annie launched an investigation.

After several characters get involved, developing psychological profiles and theories, everything is forgotten when it's announced that Pierce (Chevy Chase) died. Although Star-Burns (Dino Stamatopoulos) confessed to the crimes, the end of the episode implied that the true identity still had not been revealed. However, when the Bandit was brought up again in season 6, Annie began to look rather suspicious. Although it would seem that this Community storyline went unresolved, the clues were there, and in the 2020 Community reunion, creator Dan Harmon confirmed that the identity of the Ass Crack Bandit was indeed Annie.

6 Maggie Simpson Shot Mr. Burns

The Simpsons

Release Date
December 17, 1989
Seasons
38

One of The Simpsons' biggest whodunnits surrounded the mystery of who pulled the trigger on Mr. Burns (Harry Shearer). The two-part episode "Who Shot Mr. Burns?" built up huge suspense throughout, considering almost the entire town of Springfield had reason to shoot the business tycoon. With a long list of suspects, it was a huge plot twist when it was revealed that the shooter was Maggie, who had retaliated after Mr. Burns tried to take a lollipop from her. Despite everyone assuming it was an accident, the episode's final moments saw the baby shoot a look that implied that she'd done it on purpose, which was just all-around hilarious.