Summary

  • The Clark and Lana romance storyline was repetitive and went on for too long, overshadowing other character development.
  • Allison Mack's real world charges make her scenes as Chloe in Smallville distracting.
  • Smallville lasted for too many seasons, with the show changing significantly after its seventh season.

There are some harsh realities to rewatching Smallville 12 years after the show's series finale. Smallville is the Superman prequel series that debuted in 2001 on The WB, which later became The CW. The series starred Tom Welling as Clark Kent, chronicling his adventures as a high school student in Smallville who discovers that he has powers, and with them comes the knowledge of his past on the destroyed planet Krypton. Clark must come to terms with his dual life as a powerful Kryptonian and as a small-town teen.

While Clark's journey starts with him in high school, the series is not contained to that early premise, with 2011's Smallville season 10 presenting a very different show. Along the way, Clark met several characters that would grow to become some of DC's most popular heroes, such as Aquaman, The Flash, Green Arrow, and more. Many Superman villains also made their way onto the series, with Michael Rosenbaum's Lex Luthor, a series regular, playing a fundamental role in Clark's journey to become Superman. While Smallville is great, not all aspects of the series worked. That, and some events over the years, have led to 10 harsh realizations when rewatching Smallville.

10 Allison Mack’s Case Makes Chloe’s Scenes Distracting

Allison Mack looking toward the camera in Smallville.
Allison Mack looking toward the camera in Smallville.

Other than Welling as Clark Kent, the only main cast member to appear across Smallville's ten seasons was Allison Mack as Chloe Sullivan. Chloe was Clark's best friend right from the start of the series, with her Wall of Weird at the school's newspaper room being the best way to track all the metahumans that were popping up in Smallville. Throughout the series, Chloe would not only learn Clark's secret but also become Smallville's heroes' "woman in the chair." Sadly, years after Smallville ended, Mack was arrested due to her involvement with the NXIVM sex cult, which makes Chloe's scenes distracting.

9 Too Much Time Was Wasted On Clark & Lana’s Romance

Clark Kent and Lana Lang in Smallville TV series
Clark Kent and Lana in Smallville

Kristin Kreuk's Lana Lang started out as the girl next door that Welling's Clark Kent was pining for. Over the course of the series, Lana and Clark would get together and break up a few times, leading to a repetitive character arc that unfortunately went on for too long. More than that, Smallville appeared to not know what to do with Lana most of the time, other than having her relationships with Whitney, Jason, Clark, and Lex drive the character's story forward. With Clark and Lois Lane always destined to be together, Smallville didn't need to continue the will they or won't they between Clark and Lana for eight seasons.

8 Smallville Lasted Far Too Long

Smallville season 9 image

Smallville continued to be entertaining during all of its 10-season run; however, it's undeniable that the series ended up running for far too long, with the show likely doing better if it had bowed out with season 7. Smallville season 7 was a major year for the series, as it marked not only the final season for the show's main villain, Rosenbaum's Lex Luthor, with his departure giving the show a major blow, but also was the final season for Smallville creators Alfred Gough and Miles Millar. Starting with season 8, Smallville looked very different from how the series did early on, with very few scenes even set in Smallville.

7 Clark Kent Was Fighting Many Superman Villains Ahead Of Time

Smallville Season 8 Clark Kent and Doomsday

Smallville's early seasons featured Clark going up against regular people turned metahumans by the meteor shower that brought him to Earth as a baby. However, to remain attractive to the audience throughout its ten seasons, the DC series started to pull from the comics, introducing several Superman villains in Smallville before Clark ever turned into the Man of Steel. Among the Superman foes that Clark fought before the end of the series were iconic villains like Brainiac, Bizarro, Doomsday, and even Darkseid. Clark fighting and defeating all those villains while still fairly young creates a problem for his future as Superman, as it raises the question of what villain could possibly be able to stop him.

6 The Meteor Shower Giving People Powers Was Overused

Smallville's meteor shower was a plot device that went through a few different stages throughout the series' run. Smallville using the meteor shower to give regular people powers was a smart and creative solution to who Clark Kent should fight while he is years away from becoming Superman. The meteor shower allowed the series to have its own "villain of the week" that helped Clark discover and develop his Kryptonian powers, as well as learn about his weaknesses. However, the explanation for people's powers becoming the meteor shower ended up being overused, with every hero having the same origin soon becoming boring.

5 Smallville Could Have Used A Bigger Budget

Darkseid in Smallville Season 10 image

Smallville's special effects were fantastic for most of the series. Until the last few seasons of the show's run, Smallville's VFX, which included Clark's heat vision looking like actual fire rather than the energy beams of other Superman iterations, as well as a great display of super speed that would later develop into The Flash's special effects, ranged from looking decent to amazing. However, while it is simply impossible to expect the series to have had movie-level CGI, when the show brought in major villains like Zod, Doomsday, and Darkseid, it became clear that Smallville's budget wasn't enough to properly adapt those iconic foes, and have them fight Clark.

4 The “No Tights, No Flights” Rule Hurt Later Seasons

Clark kent Smallville Superman suit

Smallville's most important rule ended up hurting the show. Smallville's "No tights, no flights" rule was created to ensure the focus on Clark's journey to become Superman and not lose the point of the show before its end. While it made sense for most of the series, Smallville eventually changed its setting to Metropolis, with Clark working with other heroes and essentially already being Superman save for the lack of his iconic suit and ability to fly. Had Smallville season 10 allowed Clark to fully become Superman before the series finale, the show's final season would have felt more natural rather than looking like it was actively holding Clark back.

3 Smallville Laid The Path For The Perfect Superman, Only For Man Of Steel To Stray From It

Henry Cavill as Superman in Man of Steel and Tom Welling as Clark Kent in Smallville
Man of Steel and Smallville

Director Zack Snyder's Man of Steel arrived in theaters in 2013, just two years after Smallville ended. While Man of Steel borrowed elements from Smallville, the movie ended up deviating from the show's portrayal of Clark Kent. Welling's Clark is closer to the comics than Cavill's was in the movie. Although both projects try to be hopeful, Welling's version of the character is the only one to really deliver on it. Cavill's Superman lets his father die in order not to reveal his powers to others - something Welling's Clark would never do. Man of Steel also sees Superman kill Zod while Welling's Clark banished the villain to the Phantom Zone.

2 There Are Three Different Shows In One

Clark Kent Smallville
Clark Kent Smallville

Upon a rewatch, it becomes evident that Smallville can be divided into three shows. Seasons 1 through 4 of the series focused on Clark's high school adventures, showing him going up against the "villain of the week" and Clark and Lex being best friends. Then, from seasons 5 to 7, Smallville evolved into a more mature series, with Clark exploring deeper his Kryptonian heritage, Lex Luthor becoming the villain he was destined to be, and Oliver Queen's debut. Smallville's seasons 8 to 10 saw major character exits, Lois and Clark's romance finally begin, the setting shift to Metropolis, and Clark becoming Superman in all but the name and the suit.

1 Tom Welling’s Crisis On Infinite Earths Cameo Undoes Smallville

tom welling crisis

Welling came back as Clark Kent for the first time since Smallville ended for the Arrowverse's Crisis on Infinite Earths crossover. Being that Smallville laid the foundation for the Arrowverse, Welling appearing as Clark Kent in the multiversal crossover event made sense. However, Crisis on Infinite Earths essentially ended up undoing Smallville's journey. The DC series was all about showing Clark understanding and preparing for his destiny as Superman, which is why he gets the ability to fly in the series finale as he puts on the Superman suit for the first time. As such, Crisis on Infinite Earths revealing that Welling's Clark gave up his powers, undid the Smallville ending payoff.

Key Release Dates