Warning: This article contains SPOILERS for Smile 2

Although Smile 2 features plenty of choice scares, the horror sequel is missing the 2022 original’s scariest sight. In many respects, director Parker Finn’s sequel Smile 2 is an improvement on his 2022 sleeper hit Smile. The sequel is more ambitious, centering on Naomi Scott’s traumatized pop star Skye Riley instead of Sosie Bacon’s troubled psychologist. Where Smile operated at a lower register and saved its biggest shocks until its final act, Smile 2 starts big and only gets bigger. Smile 2’s opening death kills off Joel in a sequence that combines crime thriller and supernatural horror perfectly.

From thereon out, the death of Lukas Gage’s Lewis only ramps up the horror, while Skye’s rapidly worsening situation grows increasingly terrifying and surreal as Smile 2’s story continues. Smile 2’s brutal twist ending features an abortive attempt to temporarily stop the heroine’s heart, a horrific murder sequence, and a lengthy car chase, proving that Finn can deftly blend horror and action. However, the finale is missing one element that made Smile’s twist ending memorably chilling. Although the absence of one iconic villain makes sense in narrative terms, it is still hard not to miss them.

The Smile Entity's Giant Monster Form Is Missing From Smile 2

In Smile 2’s ending, the Smile franchise’s curse is embodied as a skinless fifteen-foot-tall, many-mouthed monster that reveals itself to Skye while she is onstage at a sold-out concert. This monster appeared in Smile’s ending too, but only after the demon took on a far scarier, less surreal humanoid form. In Smile’s Stephen King-inspired twist ending, the heroine Rose confronts the ghost of her mother in the dilapidated shell of her childhood home, only for this apparition to suddenly turn into an eight-foot-tall humanoid with dark lanky hair, pale white skin, and a demented rictus grin.

Skye’s ordeal with the curse isn’t identical to Rose’s journey in the original movie.

Played by actor Marti Matulis, Smile’s “Monstrosity” is one of the most memorably unsettling movie monsters in years, and the humanoid monster is much more viscerally creepy than the Lovecraftian creature that it later becomes. Despite this, Smile 2 dropped the Monstrosity and skipped straight to the monster’s wilder, less human incarnation. This does make more sense from a thematic perspective, as Skye’s ordeal with the curse isn’t identical to Rose’s journey in the original movie. Rose’s confrontation sees the demon take the form of her mother, then the Monstrosity, and then the bizarre giant demon, while Skye’s is different.

Why Smile 2 Doesn't Utilize The Original Final Monster Form

Smile 2 Is Missing The Infamous Monstrosity

Skye’s Smile 2 ending initially sees her face off against a smiling version of herself. Smile 2’s Smile Entity seemingly takes a different approach depending on its victim, meaning Skye has to confront her demonic doppelgänger whereas Rose has to deal with the Monstrosity. The real-life reason Matulis didn’t return in Smile 2 might be that he was busy with his roles in Evil and The Mandalorian, but this choice made an otherwise strong ending less scary. That said, it makes sense for the demon to bypass the Monstrosity form in Smile 2 since, ultimately, Skye’s true greatest fear is herself.

Smile 2 is currently playing in theaters.

01870910_poster_w780.jpg
Smile 2
60
8.5/10
Release Date
October 16, 2024

Cast
Rosemarie DeWitt, Naomi Scott, Lukas Gage, Miles Gutierrez-Riley, Peter Jacobson, Ray Nicholson, Dylan Gelula, Raul Castillo, Kyle Gallner, Drew Barrymore, Zebedee Row, Roberts Jekabsons, Sean Stolzen, Jon Rua, Vladimir Duthiers, Kristine Johnson, Christopher Bailey, Ivan Carlo, Christopher Sky, Jarrett Austin Brown, Erika Chase, Karma Jenkins, Daphne Zelle, Brandi Bravo
Director
Parker Finn
Distributor(s)
Paramount Pictures