Much like Life is Strange and Where the Heart Leads, South of the Circle is a narrative experience that is driven by dialogue and making moral choices. With every new chapter, the story becomes more unpredictable and engrossing; however, the game's final moments are fumbled in a way that feels confusing but emotionally resonant, resulting in a messy, compelling experience.
South of the Circle puts players in the shoes of Peter, a professor and climatologist at the University of Cambridge who is studying cloud patterns and radiation during the height of the cold war. The game wastes no time in establishing the emotional rollercoaster that is to come as it opens with Peter and a pilot named Floyd waking up from a plane crash. In a scenario similar to The Long Dark, the two have crashed in the middle of a tundra in Antarctica and, due to Floyd's broken leg, Peter must venture out alone to look for help.
Thankfully, the British research station Deception Point is within walking distance from the wreckage. As Peter limps across the tundra, it seamlessly transitions to Peter walking towards a train station sometime in the past. On the train to Cambridge, Peter stops to help a woman named Clara put her box of books on the upper shelf of her train car. Here, players get their first true experience in engaging with South of the Circle's decision system as they navigate a nervous and flirtatious conversation. Clara is another professor and, as one might expect, this moment marks the start of their relationship.
Despite being a decision-based game, the system that South of the Circle uses can make it difficult to make the best decisions possible. Rather than use traditional methods that clearly shows a full response or the emotional value of a response, South of the Circle uses symbols that are introduced in a confusing way. In the beginning moments in the plane, the symbols are accompanied by words and emotions that, in hindsight, is used to introduce what the symbols mean so the words are no longer necessary. While it's a good idea, it isn't clearly stated and so the association isn't immediately made by players who are likely to be more focused on the words than on the symbol itself. That said, players do pick up on them throughout the game and will likely stick to choosing two or three of them.
Over the course of the story, players are introduced to a variety of distinct characters who are well-written and brought to life with the help of phenomenal voice acting. Due to its time period, the story has to tackle hard subjects such as sexism, trauma, abuses of power, and the discrimination and paranoia brought on by the red scare. Thankfully, South of the Circle handles these issues wonderfully and allows the player to mold Peter into a supportive and open-minded man who values those around him just as much as he values his work. It's this strength in the game's story telling that leads to the ending's biggest weakness.
Without spoiling the finer details, the game's final sequence is filled with tension and emotion as Peter recollects the final moments of the past that lead up to his trip to Antarctica. In it, the game reflects on the key decisions made along the way and rather than respect them, seemed to ignore the work put in by players in a way that made it seem like some of the choices didn't actually matter. It may be possible that this was meant to be a narrative twist on how Peter remembers the past versus how it was, but it's entirely unclear if that's the case, which makes it all the more confusing when it happens. Despite this, the ending sequence of South of the Circle is still packed with emotional catharsis and an ambiguous ending the leaves the player wanting more, and that alone makes this game a must-play for narrative-driven players.
South of the Circle is available now on Apple Arcade and is coming to PlayStation 4, PlayStation 5, Xbox One, Xbox Series X/S, Nintendo Switch, and PC on August 3, 2022. Screen Rant was provide with a Steam download code for the purpose of this review.