One of the most iconic Spider-Man images in history is also one of the most hotly debated, with many fans claiming it isn’t even a picture of Peter Parker, while others argue that it absolutely is. So, what’s the deal with this legendary piece of Spider-Man art, and who is really under the mask?

Below is a stunning piece of Spider-Man cover art that has become one of the defining images of the superhero. The cover was drawn by John Romita Sr., inked by John Romita Jr., and colored by José Villarrubia for Peter Parker: Spider-Man #1 (1999). At first glance, it seems clear that this variant cover depicts Peter Parker’s Spider-Man.

Spider-Man Peter Parker cover-2
Spider-Man Peter Parker cover-2

However, some fans believe it actually shows Mattie Franklin, who took up the mantle after Peter stopped being Spider-Man in this series. Both sides of the Mattie versus Peter debate make strong points, and this article will break each down, leaving you to decide who you believe is truly under the mask.

Mattie Franklin vs. Peter Parker: Who Is Under the Mask?

Main Cover by John Romita Jr. & Scott Hanna for Peter Parker: Spider-Man #1 (1998)

Peter Parker spider-Man #1 main cover

This cover by John Romita Sr. is one of the most iconic images of Spider-Man, capturing not just the hero’s appearance but the soul of the character. However, it has become a topic of debate among fans, with many claiming that the figure isn’t Peter Parker at all, but rather Mattie Franklin, the female hero who briefly took up the Spider-Man mantle.

Some may be puzzled by this theory, given that Mattie is female and the Spider-Man on the cover clearly has a masculine physique. However, those who claim it’s Mattie actually have a solid argument, since in Peter Parker: Spider-Man #1, she is the one acting as the friendly neighborhood web-slinger. The comic itself therefore suggests that the Spider-Man shown could be Mattie.

This argument gains further support from the narrative, which establishes that Mattie wears a male muscle suit beneath her Spider-Man costume. This would explain why the Spider-Man on the cover appears so male. With this explanation, along with Mattie being Spider-Man in the story, the argument seems convincing, yet one crucial fact causes it to fall apart.

Spoiler: John Romita Sr. Confirms It’s Peter Parker Under the Mask

Newsstand Edition for Peter Parker: Spider-Man #1 (1998)

Peter Parker spider-Man #1 newsstand

Despite everything in the comic suggesting this is Mattie, one detail disproves that theory: the artist behind the cover. John Romita Sr., who drew the piece, confirmed that the Spider-Man on the cover is in fact Peter Parker, not Mattie Franklin. His direct confirmation outweighs the in-universe evidence presented in the issue.

This might confuse some fans since, narratively, Mattie is the male-presenting Spider-Man in that issue. However, it’s important to remember that variant covers like this one don’t always reflect the story’s events and are often artistic expression. Therefore, if the artist himself states that the person under the Spider-Man mask is Peter Parker, that remains the stronger and more definitive answer.

Peter Parker: Spider-Man #1 is available now from Marvel Comics!

Spider-Man Swinging in Dodson Comic Art
Created By
Stan Lee, Steve Ditko
First Appearance
Amazing Fantasy