Summary
- Luke Skywalker's green lightsaber in Return of the Jedi may not have been his best choice, according to a new canon reveal.
- Green lightsabers are associated with Jedi Consulars in Legends, who focus on the power and will of the Force. Blue lightsabers are associated with Jedi Guardians, who are warriors seeking to protect and defend.
- Luke's Force form is revealed to be blue, which suggests that a blue lightsaber may have been more suited for him during his final battle with Kylo Ren in The Last Jedi.
A key detail between Star Wars movies suggests Luke Skywalker had the wrong color lightsaber in Return of the Jedi. Having constructed his green-bladed lightsaber in the aftermath of The Empire Strikes Back, the canonical comics are currently revealing its origins, including the green kyber crystal Luke was given ahead of Han Solo's rescue from Jabba the Hutt where Luke's new weapon made its first on-screen debut. However, a reveal about Luke and his connection to the Force implies green might not have been Luke's best color.
After losing both his hand and the Skywalker lightsaber when Darth Vader cut it off in The Empire Strikes Back, Luke needed a new weapon going forward. While it's been revealed that Luke temporarily wielded a yellow-bladed lightsaber which once belonged to a Jedi Temple guard, the comics have recently shown that Luke now has his green kyber crystal prior to the eventual construction of a new hilt. However, Luke's continued growth in the Force in the Star Wars timeline has also revealed something rather interesting in between The Empire Strikes Back and Return of the Jedi.
Green & Blue Are Significant Colors To The Jedi
Legends Had Guardians and Consulars
It's no secret that blue and green are the most common lightsaber colors wielded by the Jedi. To that end, the pre-Disney Star Wars canon now known as Legends specified that blue was most typically associated with Jedi Guardians, those who are well-practiced in lightsaber combat as warriors seeking to protect and defend life across the galaxy (an apt description for Luke Skywalker). Conversely, green lightsaber were most often tied to Jedi Consulars, those who were best suited as diplomats while also focusing more on the power and will of the Force itself (such as Yoda or Qui-Gon Jinn).
While the distinctions between Jedi Guardians and Consulars is only part of the established canon in a very loose sense, it's rather interesting that Luke lightsaber changed to green once he built his own lightsaber, rather than keeping the blue of his father's weapon he once wielded in the first two original trilogy films. While the real-life reason is that green showed up better on-screen than blue in Return of the Jedi's opening Tatooine scenes, a new canon reveal suggests that Luke should have kept the blue.
Luke's Force Form Is Blue - Not Green
It Also Supports A Last Jedi Decision
In the months preceding Return of the Jedi, the comics have revealed that Luke has been working to master the ability of meditation, becoming more attuned and one with the Force. To that end, Luke's form in the Force has been revealed to be entirely blue. This does generate the argument that a blue lightsaber might have been better-suited for Luke all along in the Star Wars canon.
Although green has certainly become just as iconic for Luke Skywalker in the years since (especially after his appearance in The Mandalorian season 2), his Force form does justify the use of the original Skywalker saber when Skywalker faces Kylo Ren in The Last Jedi. Rather than projecting himself with his green lightsaber, Luke elected to go with the blue in his final Star Wars duel, something that now arguably makes more sense all things considered.