Disney just proved that the company learned entirely the wrong lesson from the backlash to Palpatine's return in Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker. It's safe to assume that Disney remembers all too well just how controversial and unpopular that decision was. In fact, it's often referenced as one of the biggest problems with the sequel trilogy.
There were myriad issues with this choice, ranging from the minimal explanation of how Palpatine's resurrection occurred in the movie to the fact that there was absolutely no lead up to this plot twist in Star Wars: The Force Awakens or Star Wars: The Last Jedi (because it wasn't the original plan).
It therefore makes sense that Disney/Star Wars would want to be very cautious when introducing resurrections in future projects. Sadly, the recent news that Disney rejected a Ben Solo movie, titled The Hunt for Ben Solo and backed by Kylo Ren/Ben Solo actor Adam Driver himself, cements that Disney's takeaway from Palpatine's return was all wrong.
Disney's Ben Solo Movie Rejection Was A Resurrection Problem
Adam Driver sent shock waves through the Star Wars fan base with his recent revelation that he was working on a Ben Solo movie, The Hunt for Ben Solo, for years, which would have seen Ben return from the dead following The Rise of Skywalker. This was more than just an idea, though.
On the contrary, The Hunt for Ben Solo had both a script and Steven Soderbergh signed on to direct. The script had also risen through the ranks, with Lucasfilm executives, including President of Lucasfilm Kathleen Kennedy, seeing the script and, according to Driver, loving it.
One would think that meant full steam ahead for the Star Wars movie, but that was sadly not the case. Driver revealed:
“We took it to Bob Iger and Alan Bergman, and they said no. They didn’t see how Ben Solo was alive. And that was that.”
Evidently, Disney's higher-ups couldn't envision Ben Solo's return, and that almost certainly has to do with nervousness surrounding another resurrection story and the outrage that might cause. No, that wasn't mentioned specifically, but the implications are certainly there, especially because Star Wars has proven time and again just how many ways a character can still be alive.
Resurrections In And Of Themselves Are Not The Problem
While Palpatine's resurrection may be the most well-known in Star Wars, there are so many Star Wars characters who have come back from the dead, to varying degrees of believability. Those include Darth Maul in Star Wars: The Clone Wars, Ahsoka Tano in Star Wars Rebels (and The Clone Wars, actually), and Boba Fett in The Book of Boba Fett.
Although Boba Fett's resurrection certainly had a mixed reception, perhaps in large part because it followed on the heels of Palpatine's—and it therefore started to feel like Star Wars was simply resurrecting any and everyone—other resurrections were accepted and even popular.
Darth Maul is a great example. Despite him seeming thoroughly dead in Star Wars: Episode I - The Phantom Menace, he returned in The Clone Wars, alive and bearing spider legs. He was then fully restored to his former self by the Nightsisters of Dathomir. Rather than turning heads, though, this has been a popular choice.
In fact, Maul has now returned in Rebels and even in Solo: A Star Wars Story, and he has his own show, Maul: Shadow Lord, coming up. Clearly, resurrections can therefore be done properly and be well-received. What's more, they can be done successfully post Palpatine's return, as proven by Asajj Ventress' return in Star Wars: The Bad Batch.
It seems that Disney has, therefore, unfortunately thrown the baby out with the bath water, and that's not great news for the future of Star Wars.
Disney Got This One Wrong
Unsurprisingly, given how popular Kylo Ren/Ben Solo is as a character, the news that we very nearly got a brand-new Ben Solo movie with Adam Driver enthusiastically on board but lost out because Disney said no has led to plenty of outrage from Star Wars fans.
Although not universally agreed upon, #SaveTheHuntForBenSolo has begun circulating on social media, and there's an effort by some in the fanbase to comment on various Disney executives' social media posts, insisting the movie be picked up. Whether that will be effective seems doubtful, although never say never with Star Wars.
In either case, I have no qualms about saying that rejecting this movie idea was a major misstep for Disney. The sequels are not widely regarded as Star Wars' best movies, but Ben Solo/Kylo Ren was a highlight of those movies for many, and there's clearly interest in this story being told.
Star Wars' future also constantly seems in doubt, so having a movie like this, which already had its leading actor, a brilliant director, and a script, and turning it down seems a bit foolhardy. What makes this mistake so much worse is the fact that, presumably, Palpatine's return had some sort of role to play in the decision.
This sadly means that one poor choice in The Rise of Skywalker is continuing to have a negative impact more than five years later, and it's now cost us an incredible new Star Wars movie, featuring the return of beloved character Ben Solo and equally beloved actor Adam Driver.