Star Wars' newest TV show, LEGO Star Wars: Rebuild the Galaxy - Pieces of the Past, confirms that Master Yoda really was wrong about the dark side, and it's time for Star Wars' canon movies and shows to acknowledge it too. Pieces of the Past is the sequel miniseries to Rebuild the Galaxy, and both have fun with being non-canon.

In this new installment of the show, like the first, several of the most well-known characters from throughout the Star Wars timeline are shown in completely new lights, such as Darth Jar Jar and, in Pieces of the Past, Queen Amidala as a pirate. Clearly, there's freedom and fun to be found in a non-canon Star Wars show.

However, being LEGO and non-canon doesn't keep Pieces of the Past from being meaningful in the larger franchise. On the contrary, this show has some major implications for these stories and the characters, and one of the more profound points Pieces of the Past makes proves just how wrong Yoda was about the dark side and attachments.

Star Wars Finally Gets It: Yoda Wasn't Always Right

Yoda rides on Luke Skywalker's (Mark Hamill) back as he runs through the swamps of Dagobah as part of his Jedi training in Star Wars: Episode V - The Empire Strikes Back
Yoda rides on Luke Skywalker's (Mark Hamill) back as he runs through the swamps of Dagobah as part of his Jedi training in Star Wars: Episode V - The Empire Strikes Back

Although well-known for his wisdom, Master Yoda had a stringent view of the dark side, and that's been true since his introduction in The Empire Strikes Back. In that movie, when warning Luke of the dangers of the dark side, Yoda said, "If once you start down the dark path, forever will it dominate your destiny, consume you, it will...."

This suggests that, once a person has fallen to the dark side, there's no hope of getting them back. Of course, Luke went on to prove Yoda wrong in the very next movie, as he was able to redeem his father, Anakin Skywalker, who had been living as one of Star Wars' most powerful Sith, Darth Vader, for two decades.

It therefore seemed like Star Wars recognized the issues with Yoda's strict view of the dark side and, more importantly, confirmed that attachments, be they familial or otherwise, could actually be used to save someone from a dark fate. After all, it is because Luke was Vader's son that he was able to redeem him.

Unfortunately, Star Wars decided to double down on the idea that attachments are dangerous and should be entirely avoided by Jedi. This concept was introduced in the prequels, but even in projects set after Return of the Jedi, such as The Book of Boba Fett, it's become clear that even Luke Skywalker began to view attachments as a bad thing.

Oddly, this goes entirely against what Star Wars showed audiences nearly 50 years ago, but Pieces of the Past very explicitly acknowledged that, first, Yoda was entirely wrong about the permanence of the dark side and, second, it is attachments themselves that can help someone return to the light.

Star Wars Understands The Truth At Last

Darth Dev in LEGO Rebuild the Galaxy Pieces of the Past
Darth Dev in LEGO Rebuild the Galaxy Pieces of the Past

Although many storylines are intertwined in Pieces of the Past, the main throughline is the relationship between Sig, the show's protagonist, and his brother, Dev, who has fallen to the dark side. Despite all that Dev has done, Sig still believes he is redeemable, and he specifically thinks the bond they share will save him.

Jedi Bob (his master) tells Sig that his attachment to Dev could be tainting his perspective and warns of what this could lead to, at which point Sig interjects, saying, "To the dark side? I don't believe that. What if my attachment to Dev is the only thing that's keeping him from being fully consumed? The last trace of light."

Ultimately, this proves entirely true, as it is because of Dev's love for his brother that he returns to the light side of the Force. Yes, this may seem like a repeat of a lesson Star Wars already taught audiences through Luke redeeming Darth Vader, but it's bizarrely a lesson Star Wars movies and shows have since forgotten.

In fact, all signs currently point to Star Wars continuing to cast love and attachment in this more negative light for Jedi, particularly with hints that have been dropped about Star Wars' upcoming movies.

It's Time For Disney Star Wars To Make This Idea Canon

Rey in The Rise of Skywalker looking concerned
Rey in The Rise of Skywalker looking concerned

Although stories like Luke and Darth Vader and Sig and Dev should make it obvious that love and attachment are the very things that have the power to redeem someone who has turned to evil, Star Wars may not bring that idea into canon anytime soon.

Comments by Rey actress Daisy Ridley suggest the Jedi rule against attachments will continue in Rey's movie, rumored to be titled Star Wars: New Jedi Order. Last year, Ridley was asked about Rey's relationships in New Jedi Order, specifically whether Rey might have a child. Ridley responded, “I would say she probably doesn’t have children, seeing she’s a Jedi.”

This remark certainly indicates that the Jedi rule against attachments isn't going away in Star Wars' future, which sadly makes it more than likely that the Jedi will not tap into love to save those on the dark side in the way that Luke and Sig have both successfully done now.

This really is a shame, because using love as a tool for redemption makes so much sense, especially given that Jedi are meant to be peacekeepers, driven by compassion. While a full-blown love affair like the one Anakin had with Padmé could reasonably still be frowned upon (especially how they went about it), love and attachment shouldn't be.

Hopefully, Star Wars will instead take this lesson from LEGO Star Wars: Rebuild the Galaxy - Pieces of the Past, recognize that Master Yoda was wrong about the dark side and about attachments, and confirm that love is a valid and effective way to save someone from the dark side.

Lego Star Wars Rebuild the Galaxy TV Show Teaser Poster
TV-G
Animated
Action
Adventure
Sci-Fi
Release Date
2024 - 2025-00-00
Franchise(s)
Lego Star Wars