Summary

  • Stephen Amell has expressed interest in playing Green Arrow in the new DC Universe, but it may be best for a new actor to take on the role.
  • Amell's version of Green Arrow in the Arrowverse was not comic book-accurate, which may not fit with the DC Universe's vision for its characters.
  • There are several options for where Green Arrow could debut in the DCU, including a Green Arrow/Black Canary movie or series and a potential cameo in Lanterns or as a member in the first Justice League movie.

Despite having a solid run as Green Arrow in the Arrowverse, Stephen Amell should not play Oliver Queen in the new DC Universe. Amell first played the DC character in Arrow season 1, back in 2012. The actor's ability to succeed as both the playboy billionaire and the violent vigilante sides of Oliver Queen made Arrow a hit from the get-go. The series would go on to introduce Grant Gustin's Barry Allen in its second season, setting up The Flash. Arrow ended up birthing an entire DC TV universe, the Arrowverse.

Throughout his time as Green Arrow, Amell would get to share the screen with several iconic DC heroes and villains in the Arrrowverse, including characters like Deathstroke, Ra's al Ghul, Superman, Supergirl, the Flash, and more. Arrow lasted for eight seasons, with Amell's Oliver Queen sacrificing himself to save billions, then returning as the Spectre to save the multiverse. While seeing Amell play his iconic version of Green Arrow again would be exciting, and James Gunn's new DC Universe could allow that to happen, it would be for the best that a new actor takes on the bow and arrow.

Stephen Amell Revealed He Would Play Green Arrow In The DCU

Amell Last Played Oliver Queen In The Flash Season 9

Amell's Arrow might have ended years ago, but the actor returned as Oliver Queen one more time to help Grant Gustin's Barry Allen save the multiverse in The Flash season 9, which allowed the actor who started the Arrowverse to be there for its final season. With Amell's recent return as Green Arrow and Gunn setting up his new DCU, questions began to arise as to whether Amell could appear as the DCU's Oliver Queen — similar to the campaign for Gustin to play the universe's Flash. Now, Amell has revealed that he would play the DCU's Green Arrow if asked.

Amell was blunt when questioned about playing the DCU's Green Arrow, saying, "Can we see one minute of film first? Yeah, I’d do it." Playing against Amell's chances of portraying Green Arrow again in the DC Universe are the actor and the Arrowverse's success. Gunn is creating a new universe that will stand on its own, which is why Henry Cavill's Superman and Sasha Calle's Supergirl have been recast, as will more DCEU characters. Amell's Oliver Queen is so popular that if he were to appear in the DCU, fans would be confused about its possible connection to the Arrowverse.

Stephen Amell’s Green Arrow Was Exciting, But Not Comic Book-Accurate

Smallville's Oliver Queen Was More Similar To The Comics

Oliver Queen unmasked with his arrow up in Arrow 
Oliver Queen unmasked with his arrow up in Arrow 

Besides fan confusion, there is another major reason why Amell's Green Arrow would not be the best fit for the DCU — he was not comic book-accurate. The Arrowverse's take on Oliver Queen pretty much made him the universe's Batman. While the two characters share multiple common elements, Green Arrow is a notably lighter character than the Dark Knight. However, Amell's Oliver Queen was almost always brooding and being the straight man in comedic interactions rather than the other way around, hardly ever cracking the jokes Green Arrow is known for.

As Arrow started the Arrowverse in an attempt to set up a grounded, realistic series, with other shows going on to adapt more larger-than-life heroes and stories, it made sense for Amell's Oliver Queen to start out as a more Batman-like character. However, as the years went by, only flashes of the beloved comic book version of Green Arrow would appear in Amell's performance. As Gunn has made it clear that the new DCU will be more in line with the comics, Amell's version of Green Arrow would simply not fit with the DC Universe's vision for its characters.

Where Green Arrow Could Debut In The DCU

There Are Some Good Options For Green Arrow's Live-Action Future

Arrowverse Deathstroke and Oliver Queen next to David Corenswet from Netflix's Hollywood
Arrowverse Deathstroke and Oliver Queen next to David Corenswet from Netflix's Hollywood

Gunn's Superman: Legacy will be the DCU's first movie, formally starting the universe's major projects in 2025 after the adult animated series Creature Commandos gives fans a taste of what to expect from the DCU this Fall. Besides David Corenswet's Superman, the upcoming DCU movie will include multiple heroes, indicating that several DC Comics characters are already established in the shared universe. One of those characters could be Green Arrow, whose mainstream popularity after Smallville and Arrow takes away the necessity of a DCU origin story.

After Charlie Hunman revealed he was approached to play Green Arrow, presumably for the DCEU's once planned Black Canary movie, that plan could be retooled for the DCU. A Green Arrow/Black Canary movie or series could introduce two exciting heroes to the DCU at once, finally spotlighting one of DC's best relationships. A Green Arrow solo movie with Roy Harper as his sidekick would also be great to help the DCU's worldbuilding. Oliver Queen could also cameo in Lanterns due to his friendship with Hal Jordan, and Green Arrow needs to be in the DCU's first Justice League movie.

038912_poster_w780.jpg
36
8.2/10
6/10

Arrow

Release Date
2013 - 2020-00-00
Network
The CW
Showrunner
Andrew Kreisberg
Directors
James Bamford, John Behring, Glen Winter, Michael Schultz, Wendey Stanzler, Laura Belsey, Gregory Smith, Guy Norman Bee, Nick Copus, Jesse Warn, Gordon Verheul, Antonio Negret, Kristin Windell, Thor Freudenthal, Rob Hardy, Eagle Egilsson, Dermott Downs, Joel Novoa, Kevin Tancharoen, Tara Miele, Ben Hernandez Bray, Mairzee Almas, Alexandra La Roche, Andi Armaganian
Writers
Oscar Balderrama, Sarah Tarkoff, Speed Weed, Keto Shimizu, Rebecca Bellotto, Drew Z. Greenberg, Jill Blankenship, Deric A. Hughes, Benjamin Raab, Erik Oleson, Lana Cho, Tonya Kong, Moira Kirland, Rebecca Rosenberg, Bryan Q. Miller, Jenny Lynn, Maya Houston, A.C. Bradley, Barbara Bloom, Mark Bemesderfer, Nolan Dunbar, Gabrielle Stanton, Elisa Delson, Marv Wolfman
  • Headshot Of Stephen Amell In The  F*ck Cancer Gala
    Stephen Amell
    Oliver Queen / Green Arrow
  • Headshot Of David Ramsey
    David Ramsey
    John Diggle / Spartan

Arrow is a television series that debuted in 2012, featuring Stephen Amell as Oliver Queen, a billionaire playboy who returns to Starling City after being stranded for five years. Transformed by his experience, Queen becomes a vigilante archer, aiming to purge his city of crime and corruption.