Sheriff Jim Hopper actor David Harbour is basically the coolest cat in Tinsel Town. Steve Harrington actor Joe Keery is equally as popular, constantly showcasing his undying love and support for his castmates. And then there are the kids. The young cast of Netflix's Stranger Things is talented, well-adjusted, and downright hilarious. It's obvious that the cast of this nostalgic horror series is well-loved ... but it's high time there were some real consequences to the Upside Down.It may seem as though each season of Netflix's outstandingly popular streaming series has presented us with surprising, meaningful deaths, but that simply isn't the case. When we stop and take the time to really examine the deaths of Stranger Things, we realize the writers have actually been doing all they can to keep their cast intact. While this is an understandable strategy, it is also one that will weaken the story in the long run.
Read More: Stranger Things: Biggest Questions After Season 2, Answered
He may not be the most popular character compared to Steve or Eleven, but the death of Jonathan Byers could impact the series more than any other character. Let's explore the possibilities.
- This Page: Stranger Things Needs a Meaningful Death
Stranger Things Needs a Meaningful Death
We're past the point of needing someone important to die in this show. The show has been progressively upping the stakes, causing the story to grow scarier as the children grow older. There seems to be a massive spider monster looking to bust through the Upside Down and into Hawkins. The sleepy little town has already gone from being hunted by a Demogorgon to being terrorized by a Demogorgon and Demodogs. And now we know there are others with powers out there, and they aren't all likely to be friendly like Eleven. Since season 3 seems to be upping the stakes once again, a meaningful death will be practically unavoidable.
However popular as they may be, Barbara Holland and Bob Newbie don't actually count ... they are sort of the exceptions that prove the rule. Barb, bless her, was a plot device. Her character was meant to get Nancy Wheeler and Jonathan out looking for the Demogorgon. She was an excuse to show off the town's indifference and the shady government agency's cruel manipulation. Her death does propel the story forward, but not because Barb was ever meant to be a main character or protagonist. She's Nancy's "Girl in the Fridge." Perhaps true justice for Barb would have been to make her a fully fledged character with actual purpose.
Read More: Stranger Things Season 2 Takes #JusticeForBarb Seriously
Despite his popularity, Bob Newbie is possibly a bigger offender than Barb. While being sweet and universally beloved by fans, the fledgling superhero was still a total manipulation. The writers introduced the viewers to a friendly new character that was meant to tug at the heartstrings. The audience was meant to root for this guy just so the showrunners could kill someone who would devastate the viewers without having to sacrifice any of the main cast. Remember, Bob was always meant to die, he was never supposed to be Joyce Byers' happy ending. He was a brand new character written with the sole intention of being season 2's only somewhat major death. Other than Dustin Henderson's unfortunate pets, no other season 2 victims even have names. At this point, if one of the main cast members doesn't die in season 3, viewers will lose all interest in the series. It will become all too obvious that the Upside Down is just an empty threat. Enter, Jonathan...
Why Jonathan is the Best Character to Kill Off
Jonathan Byers needs to die in Stranger Things season 3. Not because he is a bad character or dead weight, actually quite the opposite. Jonathan is a strong character whose untimely demise would have a major impact beyond the simple shock value the show has been known for thus far. At its heart, Stranger Things is about relationships. Friends, romantic unions, parents and their children. Jonathan has major ties to all three of these premises.
With Will Byers' disappearance and subsequent infection, poor Joyce has spent two seasons desperately (and successfully) trying to protect one son. Imagine how impactful and devastating it would be to watch her lose the other. Jonathan has never shied away from a fight. He's gone up against the Demogorgon and the government. He lays it all on the line to protect his family and friends. It wouldn't be a stretch for Jonathan to find himself in harm's way. Losing a major character who has been involved in the story from the very first episode would appease any complaints that the show has no real sense of danger.
How Jonathan's Death Would Change the Show
Season 2 was all about the rise of Steve Harrington and his lovable new persona, "Dad Steve." But it's important to remember that Jonathan has always been a sort of authority figure for Will in their father's absence and by extension, has acted as a sort of role model for Will's friends. Mike Wheeler went through some emotional changes in season 2 as he struggled with the loss of Eleven. Eleven herself has always been older than her years, thanks to the torture she endured at the hands of Hawkins Lab.
With Jonathan out of the picture, the rest of the boys will be forced to grow up, as well. Showrunners have already promised more "Dad Steve" in season 3, removing Jonathan from his role as Will's father figure would force Steve to become even more active in the boys' lives. It's been hinted that Hopper and Joyce are growing closer. Of course, there is plenty of room for more than one father figure in Will's life, but losing his brother would create opportunities to explore his possible new relationship with Hopper. Will he lean on the Sheriff to get through his pain? Or will he lash out at the new authority figure in his life?
Related: Stranger Things Season 3 Needs to Keep the Gang Together
Steve started out as a little bit of a jerk in season 1. He was a pretty boy with a smarmy attitude and a sense of entitlement. But he started down the path of redemption toward the end of that season, showing humility in his apologies to Nancy and putting his differences aside to aid Jonathan in his fight against the Demogorgon. He showed great maturity and character growth in season 2, quickly becoming a fan favorite, yet he still lost Nancy to Jonathan in the end. Steve's season 1 treatment of Nancy at the movie theater was atrocious. But in her grief and guilt, Nancy's treatment of Steve in season 2 was equally as hurtful and uncalled for. If she were to lose her new boyfriend, Nancy could attempt to rectify things with Steve and get back together, only for him to have moved on.
This event would allow for drama, emotion, and character growth. Unlike Nancy and Steve, Jonathan doesn't have much more room for growth. He's been forced to mature faster in order to care for his mother and brother. Sure, he's kind of weird, but it was very clear from the beginning of season 1 that Jonathan was older than his years due to his home life. Steve is on his journey to become a better person and Nancy has yet to really grapple with her feelings about Barb's death. Jonathan's arc is complete, but not overplayed. His death is the logical progression for the show and would have long-lasting implications for all of the characters involved.