Valentine's Day is right around the corner, and as such romance is in the air. Folks that celebrate this Hallmark holiday across the globe are planning date nights at steakhouses, sushi restaurants, and various other fancy dining establishments. And whether its their first date (those are some big Valentine's Day expectations!) or their 500th, impressing their date comes down to etiquette. In other words, it's all about Table Manners.
Table Manners is a self-prescribed physics-based dating simulator, but the emphasis is certainly more on the wonky physics than the actually dating part of the simulation. It imagines a world where the simplest tasks on a date - ordering food, salting said food, splitting an entree - are incredibly difficult. Think Surgeon Simulator, but with much higher stakes and much rarer steaks. It's a game made for Twitch streamers: funny enough to hold viewers' attention for a few hours, but unlikely to capture the streamer's heart.
First impressions are everything, and Table Manners certainly wears its heart on its sleeve. The controls are immediately reminiscent of other silly physics games: A and D controlling lateral movement left and right, but the mouse controlling lateral movement forward and backwards. It works against the player's brain - and how they would typically operate - to create an alienating difficulty. It's meant to be goofy, of course. And sometimes it can be delightful to accidentally send a glass flying off the table or poor wine all over your date's hamburger - but eventually the humor wears off.
The player controls just a single hand (left or right) and navigates their first-person world. In a sort of hub-menu, they can swipe left or right on a series of potential partners. "Blundr" is a clever name for a parody of modern dating apps, but the thought behind this satire ends there. All of the characters the player swipes on match - giving them plenty of people to date, both men and women. They can have functional "conversations" with their match, selecting from a series of dialogue options before and after a date. But these conversations don't go anywhere, are highly artificial (robotically-written) and don't seem to affect the dates or their progression in any way. It's more of a barrier to the gameplay than anything else.
Each date takes place in a fun and unique locale, starting with more typical places, with later levels located in low-gravity restaurants and ice bars. Players go from one scenario to the next, completely a series of four to continue on to the next location. One scenario might find the player ordering food and feeding it to their date, another lighting candles and pouring wine and beer. As the scenarios get more difficult and ridiculous, the chances of screwing up and making your date upset increase dramatically.
Players are rewarded a star-rating based on their performance on the date with points taken away for having to reorder food that was knocked off or for not completing a certain task that ones' date asks of them. These tasks pop up line orders in a cooking game, and players are given a certain amount of time to do each one before they disappear. A 3-star rating in the end rewards the player with special customizations for their in-game hand, like rings, wristbands, tattoos, and nail colors.
Table Manners can't be faulted for a lack of content. There are plenty of scenarios designed to entertain the patient player. But after an hour or so of messing about and causing mayhem in a restaurant, the appeal fades away. Sure, the graphics pop - they're delightful and colorful - and the production quality in general is top-notch, but the actual gameplay is more a lesson in futility than a lesson in chivalry. A streaming audience or perhaps even friends on a couch might find fun in watching a friend go through the motions in Table Manners, but the player themself likely won't find themselves having fun.
It's a shame, because the game is filled with missed potential. Glitches and bugs (some intentional, others not) make tasks near impossible. One such glitch involves being able to pick up chopsticks but never put them down. The level design for some restaurants - the conveyer belt sushi bar comes to mind - is brilliant, but again the novelty of hard-to-control hands doesn't ever justify the means. Even the satirical dating app, and the general "story" of Table Manners is missing something, a sort of spark. Why does the player care about one date if they can just select another date to see after? Why converse with them at all on the app if it doesn't change the story?
Table Manners does what it sets out to do, if what it wanted to do was make dating seem even more difficult than it is in reality. Its physics are fun for a time, but for those without a proclivity towards the asinine and goofy, this relationship wasn't designed to last.
Table Manners comes out on February 14, 2020 on PC for Steam. Screen Rant was provided with a digital code for the purpose of this review.