The Magicians is one of the best fantasy shows to air in the 2010s, but viewers might be looking for something else to watch after finishing its five seasons. Fortunately, there's another three-season fantasy series that makes an ideal replacement. Based on the book trilogy written by Lev Grossman, The Magicians ran for five seasons on Syfy before being canceled. It's one of many projects in the genre to meet an early end, but it has a fairly satisfying conclusion. It will leave viewers looking for other shows like The Magicians, though, and those can be hard to find.

While there are plenty of series that take place in magic school settings and transport their characters to fantastical worlds, few of them capture the tone of the Syfy series. Staying in line with Grossman's books, The Magicians puts a darker spin on these concepts. It drives home the notion that magic can't fix the characters' problems — and in many ways, it actively makes them worse. This realism, along with the complicated mental health themes and relationship dynamics, made The Magicians smarter than other shows. There is another that will probably appeal to fans, however, though it's not quite as dark.

Shadowhunters Is Similar To The Magicians In A Lot Of Ways

Both Are Urban Fantasy Series With A Heavy Character Focus

Although it doesn't subvert fantasy tropes or get quite as dark as The Magicians, Freeform's Shadowhunters has a lot in common with the Syfy series — enough that viewers should give it a shot. Like The Magicians, Shadowhunters is an urban fantasy story, pulling its main character from the real world into a magical one that ordinary people aren't supposed to know about. For Quentin, this means being accepted into a magical university, then discovering the Narnia-inspired world of Fillory isn't fiction. For Shadowhunters' Clary, it involves the realization that angels and demons are real.

Both The Magicians and Shadowhunters place a heavy focus on their characters, digging into coming-of-age themes as they do.

The larger premise of these setups feels similar, even if the two shows take their stories in totally different directions. And most importantly, both The Magicians and Shadowhunters place a heavy focus on their characters, digging into coming-of-age themes as they do. Both series take the time to unpack mental health storylines, both see their characters coming to terms with their identities, and both feature compelling friendships and romantic relationships. Anyone who wants more of those elements after watching The Magicians will find them in the Freeform series.

Shadowhunters Was A More Inconsistent Show Than The Magicians

The Quality Of The Freeform Series Varies Over Its 3 Seasons

Stephanie Bennett As Lydia Branwell In Shadowhunters
Stephanie Bennett As Lydia Branwell In Shadowhunters

While Shadowhunters boasts several strengths that also elevate The Magicians, it's worth noting that it's a more inconsistent series. It varies in quality, with some seasons and episodes feeling drastically better than others. Season 1 takes time finding its footing, both in terms of acting and writing, but it starts as an acceptable adaptation of Cassandra Clare's Shadowhunters books. As the series begins to deviate from the source material, however, it improves in other areas. This may not be enough to sway diehard book fans, but it makes it a decent watch for those who don't mind the liberties taken.

Shadowhunters was also canceled as it was gaining traction, which makes its ending less satisfying, even if its quality is an improvement on earlier outings. Not all viewers will want to slog through the less compelling visuals and storylines to get to the worthwhile ones. However, for those who don't mind the ups and downs, it's a great series to pick up after The Magicians.

Despite Its Flaws, Shadowhunters Is A Great Show For Fans Of The Magicians

It Offers An Intriguing Fantasy World & Thoughtful Coming-Of-Age Storylines

Clary and Jace holding each other on Shadowhunters
Clary and Jace holding each other on Shadowhunters

Shadowhunters has its problems, but it's still a great choice for fans of The Magicians, which isn't devoid of flaws either. Both series take significant liberties with the source material they're based on, and they both end before they should have. However, they also offer thoughtful coming-of-age storylines and intriguing fantasy worlds, and they're each unique compared to other offerings in the genre, many of which fall into the high fantasy category. They can also be binge-watched back-to-back, as they're completed. Shadowhunters is currently available to stream on Hulu.

  • 03125579_poster_w780.jpg

    Your Rating

    The Magicians
    8/10
    104
    9.2/10
    Release Date
    2015 - 2020-00-00
    Network
    SyFy
    • Headshot Of Jason Ralph
      Jason Ralph
      Quentin Coldwater
    • Headshot Of Olivia Taylor Dudley
      Olivia Taylor Dudley
      Alice Quinn

    Based on the novel of the same name by Lev Grossman, The Magicians follows Quentin Coldwater, a brilliant young man who is given a place at a magical college named Brakebills. There, he learns magic alongside his friends Alice, Eliot, Margo, and Penny, and unlocks magical secrets far beyond his wildest imaginings that see him travel to various fantastical locations, including the world of Fillory.

    Directors
    Chris Fisher, James L. Conway, Joshua Butler, John Scott, Carol Banker, Scott Smith, Guy Norman Bee, Rebecca Johnson, Salli Richardson-Whitfield, Meera Menon, Amanda Tapping, Bill Eagles, Jan Eliasberg, Kate Woods, Shannon Kohli
    Writers
    John McNamara, Henry Alonso Myers, David Reed, Noga Landau, Christina Strain, Leah Fong, Alex Raiman, Elle Lipson, David Reed
    Producers
    Sera Gamble
    Seasons
    5
  • 03106072_poster_w780.jpg

    Your Rating

    Shadowhunters
    TV-14
    Action & Adventure
    Drama
    Fantasy
    Supernatural
    14
    7.7/10
    Release Date
    2016 - 2019-00-00
    Network
    Freeform

    Shadowhunters is a television series based on the book series by Cassandra Clare. Premiering in 2016, it follows Clary Fray, who discovers her lineage and joins a group of demon hunters called Shadowhunters. As she navigates her new reality, she embarks on a mission to rescue her kidnapped mother.

    Directors
    Andy Wolk, Mick Garris, Mairzee Almas, Catriona McKenzie, Tawnia McKiernan, Salli Richardson-Whitfield, Oz Scott, Mike Rohl, Kelly Makin, Ben Hernandez Bray, Joshua Butler, Jeremiah S. Chechik, James Marshall, J. Miller Tobin, Gregory Smith, Chris Grismer
    Writers
    Peter Binswanger, Allison Rymer, Darren Swimmer, Todd Slavkin
    Producers
    Robert Shaye, Michael Lynne, Martin Moszkowicz, Mary Viola, McG, Michael Reisz, Robert Kulzer, Matthew Hastings, Y. Shireen Razack, Jamie Gorenberg, Angel Dean Lopez, David Cormican, Don Carmody, Ed Decter, Marjorie David, J. Miles Dale, Chris Hatcher, Max Yoffe, Jaromy Siporen
    Seasons
    3