As the creator of Spawn, comic creator Todd McFarlane is known for his dark and gritty style, so it makes sense that he carries a grudge against DC's champion of hope, Superman. However, it's not actually Big Blue's family friendly tone that the creator dislikes.

In a Q&A session with WIRED shared to YouTube, Todd McFarlane is asked by a fan about the good vs. evil binary in comics, and the unique place of antiheroes like Spawn. Immediately, this compels the Eisner-award-winning writer to go on a rant about Superman.

I'm gonna tell you a character I think is boring to me. Superman, and here's why: he's perfect. He says everything right. Oh, and by the way, he has the power to spin planets on his finger. And he's a boy scout. The characters I always liked were the ones that were flawed. We think that being a hero automatically makes you good. I don't. I think it's the decisions along the journey that are way, way more interesting. I have a character called Spawn. He is a completely flawed man. He lets his emotions get the better of him at times. He does things that he regrets afterward.

Todd McFarlane Think Superman Is Too Perfect

The personality types of Spawn and Superman are like night and day to each other. One is a dark, flawed, brooding anti-hero while the other is the gold standard for pure-hearted heroes. Superman arrived in comics at the pinnacle of the golden age of comic books back in 1938. Superman's success came around a time when the comics were expected to tell moral tales for children, and intended to embody "truth, justice, and the American Way." In contrast, Spawn arrived in the '90s to a very different status quo. Heroes started to become bleaker and the lines between good and evil were far murkier. Comics were also aiming at an older demographic, often embracing horror and crime as their focus.

Related: Batman & Spawn in Gritty New Crossover No-One Expected

Todd McFarlane isn't alone in his criticisms, and the criticisms themselves aren't new. As a character who has existed in comic book canon for 85 years, Superman has broadly retained his original intent - at least moreso than his Justice League contemporaries. As a result, modern readers may find Superman's sensibilities to be dated by the current standard of superheroism, especially in a time when more hard-edged comics like Invincible and The Boys are flourishing in the mainstream. Notably, several recent stories have felt the need to explain why Superman doesn't directly do more to change Earth for the better. Despite this, attempts to 'modernize' Superman have often fallen flat. Instances like Superman: At Earth's End - where Superman sports an oversized gun and a cynical attitude - are viewed as either laughable or complete character assassination.

Does Superman Need to be Fixed?

superman at earth's end
superman at earth's end

The counter-argument offered by creators such as Grant Morrison is that Superman as a character is deliberately an exploration of humanity's maximum potential - a hero who represents the best a person can be, interacting with humanity on that basis. In their book Supergods, Morrison also points out that when media such as television and movies are taken into account, Superman has remained wildly popular since his invention, suggesting this idea continues to resonate with fans and storytellers.

Ultimately, fans will make up their own minds about whether Superman is a flawed conceit in today's world, or one that just requires the right mindset - and it's worth noting that McFarlane only says he is bored of Superman, rather than suggesting the Man of Steel needs to be changed. Comics benefit from many different tones and viewpoints, and it would be hard to find two properties more opposed in their worldview than Spawn and DC's Superman.

Source: WIRED