Summary

  • Great shows can be forgotten due to outside factors like overshadowing by other shows or short-lived airtime.
  • Strong concepts and captivating performances aren't always enough to ensure a lasting place in the public's memory.
  • Shows like Preacher, Life Unexpected, and Workaholics were highly praised during their airing but faded from public conversations over time.

Sometimes, great television shows from years ago fall under the radar, leading the general public to forget about their existence. Yet, it's not always the content of the show that makes audiences forget. Oftentimes with these shows, the characters and material are spoken highly of by critics and the shows' devoted fan bases, but are forgotten due to outside factors. Whether it's because they get overshadowed by the success and popularity of other shows or their time on television screens was short-lived, they're no longer part of larger public conversations.

With more and more content being put out for audiences to enjoy, it's easy for great shows from previous years to fade from the public consciousness or to have been missed entirely. A strong concept and captivating performances by actors aren't always enough to guarantee a solidified place in the memory of television audiences. There are a few shows from the 2010s that were remarkable during their airing but whose impact faded as time passed following their series finales.

10 Preacher (2016-2019)

A Show Based On A Dark Comic Series

Dominic Cooper as Jesse Custer, looks concerned
Dominic Cooper as Jesse Custer, looks concerned 
Preacher
  • Headshot O fDominic Cooper
    Dominic Cooper
  • Headshot Of Ruth Negga
    Ruth Negga
  • Headshot Of Joseph Gilgun
    Joseph Gilgun
  • Headshot Of Ian Colletti
    Ian Colletti

Release Date
May 22, 2016
Network
AMC
Seasons
4

Preacher, based on the comics of the same name by Garth Ennis and Steve Dillon, starred Dominic Cooper, who played a preacher with the supernatural ability to make others do as he says. The first two seasons of the series were highly praised by audiences and critics. Among the praises were comments about the gore and horror elements, as well as the quality of adapting the comic material into a series. However, the final season's reviews and ratings were inconsistent with the previous seasons, making Preacher as a whole drop from much of the public conversation, especially as a series based on another Ennis comic, The Boys, was just starting.

9 Life Unexpected (2010-2011)

A Family Reunited Under Unique Circumstances

Cate (Shiri Appleby) talking to her daughter Lux (Britt Robertson)
Cate (Shiri Appleby) talking to her daughter Lux (Britt Robertson)

Life Unexpected was a CW television series that followed the life of Lux, played by Britt Robertson, as she reunites with her birth parents after spending much of her life in the foster care system. The series received positive comparisons to other shows such as Gilmore Girls for its heartfelt storylines. Even with the CW's attempt at improving the series' ratings by having crossover episodes with their popular series One Tree Hill, Life Unexpected was unable to garner a large audience and was canceled after two seasons.

Related: The CW: 10 Shows That Everyone Forgot About

8 Workaholics (2011-2017)

A Sitcom That Originated In Friendship

Blake, Adam, and Anders in the office
Blake, Adam, and Anders in the office

Release Date
March 4, 2011
Network
Comedy Central
Seasons
7

Workaholics was a sitcom that ran for seven seasons on Comedy Central. The series followed the hysterical dynamics and day-to-day lives of three roommates who met in college, but now work at a telemarketing company. The three leads of the series, Blake Anderson, Adam DeVine, and Anders Holm started as a comedy group called Mail Order Comedy. An executive from Comedy Central saw Mail Order Comedy's videos and thus began the start of Workaholics. The last two seasons of Workaholics saw lower ratings and, combined with the actors' careers after the series ended, it caused most of the public to forget the once-favored sitcom.

7 The Night Manager (2016)

The Miniseries Is Short-Lived In Audience's Memory

Release Date
February 21, 2016
Seasons
2

As a six-part series, The Night Manager was a British television series based on the 1993 novel, by John le Carré, about an operation to bring down the workings of an arms dealer. The series starred Tom Hiddleston and Hugh Laurie as the leads. According to critics, the television series seemed to be the best fit for Carré's novel, as opposed to a film. While The Night Manager might have been forgotten due to its miniseries structure, in February 2023 it was reported that a second and third season could be in the works with Hiddleston and Laurie returning, though nothing's been confirmed.

6 United States Of Tara (2009-2011)

Balancing Comedy And Mental Health Portrayal

Tara (Toni Collette) looking at her husband
Tara (Toni Collette) looking at her husband 

Following the life of a mother and wife diagnosed with dissociative identity disorder, United States of Tara starred Toni Collette as the titular character. The series ran for three seasons but was ultimately canceled before a fourth could wrap everything up. Audiences and critics alike praised much of the series for its handling and portrayal of Tara's mental health and the balance between the series' comedic and dramatic tones. There's no definitive reason as to why the series has managed to slip out of the public consciousness, but Collette managed to win two awards for her lead role and has continued to work as a celebrated actress.

5 Happy Endings (2011-2013)

A Sitcom With An Exciting Start And Unfortunate Ending

Jane, Brad, Max, Penny, and Alex laughing and standing outside
Jane, Brad, Max, Penny, and Alex laughing and standing outside
Happy Endings
  • Headshot Of Adam Pally In The Los Angeles Premiere Screening Of Sonic
  • Headshot Of Eliza Coupe
    Eliza Coupe
  • Headshot Of Elisha Cuthbert
    Elisha Cuthbert
  • Cast Placeholder Image
    Zachary Knighton

Release Date
April 13, 2011
Network
ABC
Seasons
3

Happy Endings was a sitcom that followed the lives of six friends after a couple in the friend group ended their relationship. The friends then managed to continue their friendship despite the change in their dynamic. The show aired for three seasons on ABC but saw multiple changes in its programming placement with each season. The continuous moving around of Happy Endings' airtime caused ratings to drop, therefore, Happy Endings ended after three seasons. Despite the dedicated fan base and positive critical reviews surrounding the series, its confusing schedule is likely the reason many television fans forget the show's existence or miss it entirely.

4 Sense8 (2015-2018)

Diverse Characters Connected To One Another And To Audiences

Sense8

Release Date
June 5, 2015
Seasons
2
Streaming Service(s)
Netflix

Eight strangers learn they are connected, both emotionally and mentally. Sense8 was a sci-fi series released on Netflix and was highly celebrated for its LGBTQ+ diverse cast within the sci-fi genre. Throughout its two seasons, the characters' diverse stories and the writing garnered positive reviews. While the series grew a dedicated fan base, one that pressured Netflix to release a movie-length series finale, it wasn't enough to support the budget of the show. Therefore, the reason Sense8 is forgotten about by general audiences is largely due to its cancelation.

3 The Magicians (2015-2020)

The Fantasy Series With Dark Elements

Alice, Kady, and Quentin
The Magicians
  • Headshot Of Jason Ralph
    Jason Ralph
  • Headshot Of Olivia Taylor Dudley
    Olivia Taylor Dudley
  • Headshot Of Arjun Gupta
    Arjun Gupta
  • Headshot Of Stella Maeve
    Stella Maeve

Release Date
December 16, 2015
Network
SyFy
Seasons
5

The Magicians is based on the fantasy novels by Lev Grossman. The series follows Quentin Coldwater as he and other students at Brakebills University for Magical Pedagogy discover a magical world full of dangerous threats. The Magicians is known for its darker elements. While controversial at times, it's these bold tones and the world-building throughout the series that drew audiences in. The Magicians was given positive feedback and the series naturally grew with each season, leaving fans devasted about the fifth season being the finale. The reason The Magicians can be forgotten by the public is likely due to the Syfy network not being as popular as its competitors.

2 Rectify (2013-2016)

A Series Too Slow For Audiences To Remember

Daniel Holden (Aden Young) walking with a book in his hand
Daniel Holden (Aden Young) walking with a book in his hand

Following his release from prison after a wrongful conviction, Daniel Holden returns to an unwelcoming hometown. The show is known for its slow pacing and, while some complained that the story moved too slowly, fans and critics complimented the pace, noting the series taking its time with the material and the slow burn making the series rewarding. While many critics have listed the series among their lists of top television series throughout its run, Rectify did air as the first scripted original series on SundanceTV. This, along with the slow pacing that drove general audiences away, led to the show being forgotten about after its series finale.

1 One Day At A Time (2017-2020)

A Modern Take On A Classic Sitcom

One Day at a Time
  • Headshot Of Justina Machado
    Justina Machado
  • Headshot Of Todd Grinnell
    Todd Grinnell

Release Date
January 6, 2017
Seasons
4
Streaming Service(s)
Netflix

Roughly based on the 1975 sitcom of the same name, One Day at a Time is centered around a Cuban-American family and deals with issues such as immigration, sexuality, and racism. The show was noted as bringing a fresh and modern take to the 70s classic. After three seasons on Netflix, the streaming service canceled the series. However, the fourth season was picked up by Pop TV and six episodes aired.

With the COVID-19 pandemic putting a pause on production, the remaining episodes were never put out and the series ended in 2020. The switch to another distributor likely left original fans behind and a six-episode season wasn't enough to draw new fans in. This resulted in the acclaimed sitcom fading from the public's memory.

Related: 10 Best Bits Of Parenting Advice From One Day At A Time