Twitch is suing two users for targeting Black and LGBTQIA+ streamers with hate raids that brought harassing and hateful content to their streams, including racist, homophobic, and sexist content. The lawsuit comes over a month after the "hate raids" started on the platform against marginalized streamers. The rampant hate raids and lack of action from Twitch eventually led to a platform-wide protest from streamers and viewers at the beginning of September.
Hate raids occur when a large number of bots (fake computer-generated accounts) spam and harass a streamer in their chat while they are live, often with racist, homophobic, sexist, and other hateful and bigoted content. In early August, marginalized streamers, specifically streamers of color, were noticing an increase in these raids. The lack of action and response from Twitch to prevent or help stop these hate attacks led to the hashtag #TwitchDoBetter, which ended up trending on Twitter, and eventually forced Twitch to respond with changes. However, this did not stop the hate raids, though some streamers did acknowledge that they were no longer "as bad" as before. This led to streamers across the platform holding a protest, #ADayOffTwitch, to show solidarity to those who were impacted by the hate raids and to get the attention of Twitch so they could do better.
Twitch filed the lawsuit last week (September 9) against "Cruzzcontrol," based out of the Netherlands, and "CreatineOverdose" based out of Vienna, Austria (via Wired). To initially fight the hate raids, Twitch banned thousands of accounts and created new chat filters to help the chat's automod. According to the lawsuit, these two accounts were swiftly suspended and permanently banned but it did not stop them. "They evaded Twitch’s bans by creating new, alternate Twitch accounts, and continually altering their self-described ‘hate raid code’ to avoid detection and suspension by Twitch," the lawsuit states. Unfortunately, the suit claims both Cruzzcontrol and CreatineOverdose are still on Twitch, operating under multiple aliases and thousands of bots. Further, the lawsuit states that both users self-proclaimed they can generate thousands of bots in minutes to continue conducting the hate raids.
As part of their initial response to #TwitchDoBetter, Twitch announced they were working on channel-level ban evasion detection and account verification improvements later in 2021, in an effort to improve the safety of Twitch users. However, part of the problem with bots is as one is found, two more can pop up. When speaking to Wired, a Twitch spokesperson said "[t]he malicious actors involved have been highly motivated in breaking our Terms of Service, creating new waves of fake bot accounts designed to harass Creators even as we continually update our sitewide protections against their rapidly evolving behaviors." The lawsuit shows this by including a specific example from CreatineOverdose. On August 15, four days after Twitch announced the channel-level ban evasion detection they were working on, CreatineOverdose, the suit states, demonstrated how their both software could spam channels with "racial slurs, graphic descriptions of violence against minorities, and claims that the hate raiders are the KKK."
The hit #ADayOffTwitch caused Twitch was noticeable and highlighted other issues the platform has as a whole and has some streamers feeling hopeful. Raven, also known as the Twitch streamer RekItRaven, said “The people who are behind this need to be held accountable for their actions. They've terrorized hundreds if not thousands of people. If this were to happen in a physical location we'd expect the same. It shouldn't be any different online.” Time will tell if this lawsuit alleviates the problem of hate raids.
Source: Wired