2023 has turned into something of a remarkable year for games set at sea. Whether it's the absolute delight that is Dave The Diver or the horror catch-of-the-day that is Dredge, a nautical setting has proved very evocative for gamers this year. Enter Under The Waves, from developer Parallel Studio and publisher Quantic Dream, which takes an introspective and psychological approach to the depths.

Under The Waves is the story of Stan, a professional diver who works for the UniTrench drilling company in the North Sea. After a tragic loss in his family, Stan takes on an underwater job, but everything is not quite as it seems. The narrative adventure shifts between a focus on Stan's grief and a wider story about the oil conglomerate as a whole, and players will likely come away with an appreciation for its storytelling and world building, but perhaps less so for its actual mechanics.

A Crushing Atmosphere

Under The Waves Cave
Under The Waves Cave

Where Under The Waves absolutely excels is with the way that it delivers the sense of being underwater. The game recreates the oppressive nature of the deep sea really well, effortlessly sliding between the beauty of the natural world of the ocean and the danger of the depths. It never quite reaches the true horror of Soma, which is perhaps the gold standard for underwater fear in video games and one of the scariest independent horror games ever made, but its dark, cramped moments in deep sea oil facilities that are coming apart at the seams are extremely tense.

Under The Waves is often absolutely gorgeous, too. Parallel Studio creates a world of contrast, between the sheer volume of life in the vibrant blue of the ocean at large and the murky depths where UniTrench has made its presence known. It's worth noting that Under The Waves does utilize a chromatic aberration effect throughout, as well as often shifting and tilting the camera, and although these are very effective at creating a sense of underwater activity, it is worth knowing about if a potential player is susceptible to motion sickness or sensitivity to those kinds of visual effects.

Alongside the visual element, it's worth noting just how impactful the score is, too. The soundtrack, from Nicolas Bredin, matches the tone of the overall project effortlessly, whether the bittersweet moments that Stan has when trying to find peace or the crushing tension found elsewhere. All in all, Under The Waves makes its presence known.

Exploring Story Depths

Under The Waves Moon Submersible
Under The Waves Moon Submersible

From a storytelling perspective, Under The Waves straddles two key thematic elements, although it does try to tie the two together. Although the core personal story relates to Stan and his grief, the game also has a strong conservation and environmental core. This perhaps isn't surprising given the involvement of the non-profit organization Surfrider, and by combining these two worlds Under The Waves manages to create a story that falls somewhere between Solaris and The Abyss.

Perhaps the stronger focus of the two is in the ecological side. UniTrench and its 1970s-esque techno-futurism is a suitably mysterious, faceless and suspicious organization, and its setup as an untrustworthy group feels completely in line with reality. After all, with behemoths like Shell and Exxon covering up climate change in the 1980s and funding climate change denial well into the modern day, the actions taken by UniTrench in this game feel almost quaint.

The exploration of grief, meanwhile, is a little more cumbersome. Although it improves as time goes on, and provides a finale of tremendous emotional impact, there's an awkwardness in the early stages that takes away a little of its power. In part this is down to dialogue, with Stan regularly explaining to himself - as a solitary party under the water - how he is doing. Although the voice acting is generally excellent, with plenty of pathos, this could potentially have been better portrayed by more subtle means.

Some Technical Hiccups

Under The Waves Machinery
Under The Waves Machinery

This clumsiness also feeds through to a lack of polish in other areas. Although Under The Waves is perfectly functional, the clunky feel of its controls does mean that the player may feel a little bit exasperated as time goes on. Equally, although its setup as an open world with story missions separated into different days does mean that exploration is very enjoyable, the crafting focus of its gameplay feels a little more arbitrary, and players may well find themselves skipping the crafting mechanics except when absolutely necessary.

There are some other technical issues that may take the player out of the moment, although thankfully the game is so atmospheric that such lapses are soon forgotten. Sometimes when shifting between walking on a platform and swimming the animations can feel a little odd, or Stan may not land quite where the player would expect, which impacts on the fluidity of the experience. Meanwhile, the ambient dialogue can also sometimes trigger in odd places; during a particularly tense scene towards the end of the game, the player may find themselves using a mine to blow the lock off an airlock door only to hear Stan say “there we go!” in a chipper fashion.

Some of these issues will hopefully be resolved with patches, such as some sloppy quest markers here and there that point the player in the wrong direction, and in fact it's often better when exploring to turn off the HUD altogether for a more impressive experience. It's worth noting that none of this is game-breaking whatsoever, but there are a few niggling issues that when resolved could definitely elevate the overall experience.

Our Review Score & Final Thoughts

As a whole, Under The Waves is a truly immersive narrative-driven game. Although sometimes a little heavy-handed with themes that could do with more subtlety, overall its message is powerful and the atmosphere the game creates is second to none. It is, however, hampered by a few moments of technical clumsiness that stop it from being quite as effective as it could be.

Source: Quantic Dream / YouTube

Under The Waves is out now for PC, PS4, PS5, Xbox One, and Xbox Series X/S. Screen Rant was provided with a PS5 code for the purposes of this review.