There’s a wide variety of detective TV shows to choose from, but the big hits have overshadowed some truly great shows. The genre of detective shows has a couple of titles among the best TV shows of all time, such as Mindhunter and the BBC’s Sherlock, and there are many others that continue to be quite popular, as is the case with Criminal Minds.
While many great detective TV shows have rightfully earned a lot of praise from critics and general audiences, many other good shows have faded into obscurity. These shows didn’t get the success they deserved, not because of their quality but because of a lack of proper marketing, fierce competition, or, simply, it wasn’t their time just yet.
Psych
2006-2014
The main character of Psych is one of those characters who tried to be the next Sherlock Holmes and failed, but the show is quite good as its own thing. Psych is a detective comedy-drama created by Steven Franks, and it follows Shawn Spencer (James Roday), a young crime consultant for the Santa Barbara Police Department.
Spencer stands out for his incredible observational skills and photographic memory, which are of great help while investigating crimes. Accompanying him is his intelligent best friend Gus (Dulé Hill), forming a very fun pair. Psych is a fun mix of engaging mysteries, witty humor, and the great dynamic between Spencer and Gus, and it’s perfect for those looking for some comedy in their detective shows.
Almost Human
2013-2014
Almost Human is a sci-fi crime drama TV series created J. H. Wyman. Almost Human takes the audience to the year 2048, where the evolution of science and technology has caused crime rates to rise to unbelievable levels. Because of this, the police force has implemented a new policy where every human officer is paired with a lifelike combat-model android.
After a traumatizing experience that left him in a coma, with a cybernetic prosthetic leg, and huge gaps in his memory, Detective John Kennex (Karl Urban) is recalled to the force and paired with an android named Dorian (Michael Ealy). Aside from the action side of Almost Human, its best part is the growth of the relationship between Kennex and Dorian.
Ripper Street
2012-2016
Ripper Street is a British mystery drama TV series created by Richard Warlow. Set in 1889 East End of London, six months after the Jack the Ripper murders, Ripper Street follows Detective Inspector Edmund Reid (Matthew Macfadyen), who is haunted by his failure to capture Jack the Ripper.
Along with his team, Reid works to maintain order in the area following the Ripper’s atrocious crimes. The cases Reid and company investigate sometimes make people think the Ripper has returned, so it’s up to them to bring calm and safety back. The atmosphere, characters, and cases are what make Ripper Street a detective show worth checking out.
Marcella
2016-2021
Marcella is a British Nordic noir detective TV series created by Hans Rosenfeldt and Nicola Larder. Marcella follows Marcella Backland (Anna Friel), a former London detective who returns to work to investigate an open case from 11 years earlier. The serial killer from that case seems to have returned to commit more murders, and Backland is determined to catch them.
Marcella leans more toward psychological drama, with a compelling lead character, engaging murder mysteries, and lots of drama with Backland’s personal struggles. Marcella explores the title character's trauma and inner demons, parallel to the mysteries that come with dark twists.
Grimm
2011-2017
Grimm is a fantasy police procedural drama series based on the Brothers Grimm’s Grimm’s Fairy Tales. Grimm introduces homicide detective Nicholas Burkhardt (David Giuntoli), who finds out he’s a Grimm, the latest in a line of guardians whose mission is to keep the balance between humans and mythological creatures.
This touch of fantasy is what makes Grimm unique among detective shows, along with its inspiration from classic (but dark) fairy tales. Grimm gives an engaging twist to the genre, but without leaving aside humor, character development, and entertaining stories.
The Sinner
2017-2021
The Sinner is a police procedural anthology TV series based on Petra Hammesfahr’s 1999 novel of the same name. Each season covers a new story, with the first one following detective Harry Ambrose (Bill Pullman) investigating why a woman named Cora stabbed a man to death.
Season 2 followed Ambrose as he returned to his hometown, where a young boy had confessed to poisoning a couple. Season 3 saw Ambrose investigating a fatal car accident, and in season 4, a now-retired Ambrose is recruited to help in an investigation involving the daughter of a prominent family. The Sinner is unpredictable, engaging, and has great performances.
Criminal
2019-2020
Criminal is a police procedural anthology TV series streaming on Netflix. Each episode covers a different case, and it takes the audience into the interrogation room as a team of police investigators tries to get to the truth. Criminal has four series: France, Germany, Spain, and UK, with the latter being the only one with two seasons.
Criminal is suspenseful and engaging, as the audience follows the interrogations quite closely, learning about the suspects and their involvement in the cases at the same time as the characters. Criminal is a perfect replacement for Mindhunter, though with fictional stories.
Wallander
2008-2016
Henning Mankell’s character Kurt Wallander has gotten different adaptations, and for this list, I’m going with the British version, starring Kenneth Branagh. Wallander is a police detective inspector in the small town of Ystad, Sweden, but in addition to the weight of the cases he investigates is the weight of his personal problems.
More often than not, Wallander is more a drama show than a detective one, but seeing the title character being vulnerable makes the show stand out among the best of the genre. What further elevates this show is Branagh’s performance, which, unfortunately, is one of his most underrated ones.
Luther
2010-2019
One of the best and most underrated detective TV shows of all time is Luther, created by Neil Cross. Luther centers on Detective Chief Inspector John Luther (Idris Elba), who, after a confrontation gone wrong with a serial killer leaves the latter in a coma, suffers a nervous breakdown. Some time later, Luther returns to work.
His first case is a double homicide, with the victims’ daughter, Alice Morgan (Ruth Wilson), being the main suspect. What follows are Luther’s efforts to solve this and other cases, while Alice shows that she’s actually a brilliant but dangerous mind.
Luther is darker than most detective shows, and its title character tends to use unorthodox methods in his investigations. Luther can also be impulsive and aggressive, which more often than not gets him into trouble.
Pushing Daisies
2007-2009
Pushing Daisies is one of those great TV shows that were canceled too soon, but it’s also a painfully underrated detective show. Created by Bryan Fuller, Pushing Daisies is a comedy-drama TV series that introduces viewers to Ned (Lee Pace), a pie-maker with a unique ability: he can bring dead things back with his touch.
However, if something is brought back for more than one minute, a similar “life value” in the vicinity dies to regain balance. If Ned touches the revived person or animal again, they die permanently. Ned uses this ability to solve crimes when he partners with private investigator Emerson Cod (Chi McBride).
Ned brings murder victims back to life for less than a minute to ask them details that can help them solve their cases. Ned’s life takes a turn when his crush, Chuck (Anna Friel), dies and he brings her back, but he can’t touch her again.
Pushing Daisies is unlike any other detective TV show, with its whimsical visual style, sense of humor, and emotional depth, and it deserved a lot better than a sudden cancellation.