Why are critics split on Amazon's Utopia remake? Created by Dennis Kelly, Utopia first aired on UK screens back in 2013 and ran for two seasons before being controversially axed on a massive cliffhanger. Despite its fleeting existence, the original Utopia attracted a strong cult following that hasn't entirely given up hope for a continuation. A US Utopia remake appeared on the horizon as early as 2014, with David Fincher lined up to put his own unique spin on Kelly's visceral and violent conspiracy tale. Although the Fincher project never took off, the idea of remaking Utopia for a US audience remained, with Amazon Prime stepping in and Gillian Flynn taking over as showrunner.
Amazon's Utopia stars Rainn Wilson as Dr. Sterns, Sasha Lane as Jessica Hyde, Dan Byrd as Ian and John Cusack as Dr. Christie. The central core of characters remain consistent with the British original, with new figures such as Cusack's Dr. Kevin Christie adding a fresh take. Utopia begins with a mysterious comic book, which some fans claim holds the key to a vast, global conspiracy. A group of said fans soon find themselves out of their depth and confronted with a global viral pandemic.
While the new Utopia always faced an uphill struggle winning over fans of the original, the majority of Amazon's audience will likely come without expectations, allowing the Utopia remake to be judged on its own merits. Unfortunately, the verdict has been far from unanimous thus far, sitting at 58% on Rotten Tomatoes at the time of writing. Utopia has been typically divisive, hitting a middle ground with many, but falling completely flat with others. Here's a flavor of the mixed reviews Utopia has been enjoying:
The season consists of eight energetic, propulsive episodes, each unfolding like a chapter of an addictive crime novel. Unlike many streaming dramas given as many minutes as they like to tell their plodding story, “Utopia” flies right by. But for a show that’s essentially a series of puzzle boxes, its mysteries are all too easy to solve. For every genuine surprise, there are five more “twists” that were telegraphed from five miles away.
If you’ve never seen the original British series, the new version will appear intriguing enough. It pales in comparison to the original, however. Dennis Kelly’s series is quirky, visually-striking and surprising. Gillian Flynn’s version, in contrast, has taken all of its originality out, and its very dark humor, with only the bare bones of the storyline intact and slightly less brutal violence. Flynn’s version resembles any other regular TV shows.
This version, with its thick budget and big American names helicoptered in to make ordinary scenes memorable, feels sanitised by comparison. The ultraviolence comes in cartoon colours – a movie sheen in place of forbidding suburban grey and queasy neon. Unlike the original, which made you feel as if a cold hand had grabbed your ankle and made you pratfall into a puddle of acid, this is devoid of menace – and wit.
Reviews for Amazon's Utopia are praising the conspiracy thriller vibes and the violent action, painting the series as a competent, if unspectacular, story with plenty of twists and turns. But reviews frequently cite two major issues that have contributed greatly to Utopia's lukewarm reception. The first is the current coronavirus pandemic. Although the idea came from the UK series, Amazon's Utopia puts more emphasis on the deadly global flu pandemic plot point. Many critics feel that Utopia has suffered from its awkward timing, released in the middle of a real-world pandemic, although the series was written and filmed prior to COVID-19. The second major issue appears to be comparing the new Utopia to its UK counterpart. Many reviews accuse the remake of simply being a toned-down, less exciting version with the original's unique elements mostly stripped away - not an inherently bad remake, but perhaps an unnecessary one. Some reviews, however, have gone further:
The problem is that, even with its end-of-the-world urgency, this Utopia still feels sluggish, muddled, unfinished. It’s as if someone went to great pains to restore a classic car, added their own custom interior, and then forgot to fill up the tank with gas.
What you need to know about “Utopia,” is that it’s grim to the point of being hostile, clumsy in critical character-centric moments, and an otherwise efficient dystopian thriller.
THR:
Of course, even the most distasteful or hackneyed starting point can serve as the origin of an incredible journey. But Utopia’s first seven episodes demonstrate that there’s not enough specificity to the characters or fascination in the season-long mysteries to provide the bloody escapism that Flynn intended.
Based on this selection of reviews, it's clear that Utopia's problems go beyond the unfortunate timing of its release and the shadow of a beloved predecessor. While there's no single element that critics are outright lambasting, there's also nothing garnering universal praise, with characters, twists and visuals all afford a "could've been better" verdict. Love it or hate it, the UK's original Utopia series was a stark contrast to anything else on TV, and this bloody-minded uniqueness was its greatest strength, as well as its downfall. Amazon's Utopia takes a more conventional approach, and has failed to strike a chord with critics as a result.