B.J. Novak has always been a multihyphenate talent, but that fact has never been as clear as it is in his feature film Vengeance, arriving in theaters on July 29. Novak writes, directs, produces and stars in the satirical murder mystery, which centers on a New Yorker who travels to western Texas for the funeral of a girl he once hooked up with. Upon learning that Abilene Shaw's family thinks he was her loving boyfriend, Ben Manalowitz finds himself trapped in a web of lies that points to foul play.

What does Ben do with the information of Abilene's potential murder, provided with rage and sincerity by her brother Ty (Boyd Holbrook, The Sandman)? Start a podcast, of course. With the help of his producer Eloise (Issa Rae, Insecure), Ben tries to turn the story of the Shaw family's deluded grief into a metaphor for America and the deceptions it feeds itself. While Novak has been writing and directing since his days as Ryan Howard on The Office, Vengeance marks a cinematic shift that will hopefully last a long time.

Related: What BJ Novak Has Done Since Leaving The Office

Screen Rant spoke to Novak about the pressure of working on his first feature film, how he landed on the themes of Vengeance, and why he wanted to impress Issa Rae so badly.

VENGEANCE (2022) - BJ Novak & Boyd Holbrook (L to R) Clint Obenchain as Crawl, B.J. Novak as Ben Manalowitz and Boyd Holbrook as Ty Shaw in Vengeance. Credit: Patti Perret/Focus Features

Screen Rant: You're writing, you're directing, you're producing and you're starring in Vengeance. All hands on deck are your hands. How did you prepare for that experience?

BJ Novak: Well, I was scared. And I liked that, because it means that you're trying something brave and out of your comfort zone. But it doesn't mean I wasn't panicked. So, I turned to everyone I could for advice, both as an actor and as a leading man. I asked John Mayer, like, "How are you so handsome?" And he was like, "lose a little weight, stop drinking, you'll be fine." [Laughs]

But honestly, I was scared over every detail. And I especially turned to a lot of director friends for advice and encouragement every step of the way. A friend of mine, Mark Webb, gave me a lot of great wisdom; John Lee Hancock, who I've worked with a lot. It was really turning to people for advice.

That's wonderful. I'm glad their advice worked, because there are so many layers to the story and to the mystery that it really has me thinking about it a week after I have seen it. How much was the podcast culture and the disassociation from humanity a reflection of your own reality, or what you've seen?

BJ Novak: It's definitely the world I live in; that we all live in. And I think, ironically - and this is just sort of my theory, it's not necessarily the point of the movie - but it does feel to me that the things that we think are connecting us are not, and vice versa.

We are connected to other opinions through podcasts, other voices. We are literally hearing other voices in our heads. And yet, is that connection? Or does that make us have sort of a menu of humanity, where you can choose a person anytime to say whatever you want them to say?

And same with playlists instead of albums. That comes up in the movie too. A lot of it is about music and recording. I'm a playlist guy; I don't like that. I get a Spotify list, and I think, "Oh, I love all the songs!" But I don't look up the artist, you know? It's sort of like we have this menu of people that we can choose from without actually getting to know people and all their complexity; all their good and bad sides.

This movie is about someone who comes from that exact culture and ends up deeply involved with his family.

Issa Rae as your producer was an inspired choice. What was that experience like, getting to direct her and just be chatting with her all the time?

BJ Novak: That was the person that I was most intimidated to impress. It was my first time directing, and I didn't know the crew and how the set would go.

And here's this person who's here for one week, just acting. She's taking a break because she wanted to do it for whatever lucky reason. She's taking a break from probably producing 20 shows herself. I did not want to waste her time or make her think that I was an amateur. I was really on my best leadership behavior that week and the crew ended up being incredible.

Vengeance Synopsis

VENGEANCE (2022) - BJ Novak & Ashton Kutcher (L to R) Ashton Kutcher as Quentin Sellers and B.J. Novak as Ben Manalowitz in Vengeance. Credit: Patti Perret / Focus Features

A journalist and podcaster travels from New York City to Texas to investigate the death of a woman whom he hooked up with.

Check out our interview with Vengeance star Boyd Holbrook as well.

More: B.J. Novak’s 10 Best Roles, Ranking According To IMDb

Vengeance arrives in theaters on July 29 through Focus Features.