Summary

  • Vibranium is a scientifically plausible concept, but its properties in the MCU defy logic, such as its ability to absorb sound and redirect kinetic energy.
  • Tony Stark's creation of a new element in Iron Man 2 goes against real-world physics, as creating stable, non-radioactive elements requires a lot of energy and is highly unlikely.
  • Pym Particles violate the Square-cube law of physics, allowing for the manipulation of mass and strength, which is impossible to achieve in the real world.

Vibranium is one of the many weird substances unique to the Marvel Cinematic Universe that has abilities unexplainable by real-world science. Some of these substances are magical in nature, suggesting there is no reason why they should conform to normal physical laws. Yet there are other substances that are treated as legitimate scientific wonders, which makes their refusal to follow the laws of physics vexing to those who demand a certain level of realism in their science fiction.

As legendary comic writer Stan Lee noted (in the 2002 documentary Stan Lee's Mutants, Monsters & Marvels), "I love science fiction, but nobody knows less about science than I do." Lee freely admitted to building the Marvel Universe around terms that sounded good, like "gamma bomb" or "cosmic rays," but were completely unsupported by real science. The MCU continues this tradition, boasting a number of strange substances that defy explanation.

8 Vibranium

Black Panther and Vibranium int he MCU.
Black Panther and Vibranium int he MCU.

Logically, the base concept of Vibranium is scientifically sound. There are a number of rare elements, such as ruthenium and osmium, which are frequently found in meteorites. There is also one metal, Technetium, which is only found in meteorites and does not occur naturally on Earth. It is plausible that a nation like Wakanda could build its wealth around a limited supply of such a rare metal. It is when the properties of Vibranium are examined, however, that the idea begins to fall apart.

Naturally, Vibranium takes its name from its unique ability to absorb sound waves, or vibrations. It also has some finite ability to absorb and redirect kinetic energy. Granting that some real metals have similar properties of sound-proofing and energy transfer, the movies are inconsistent regarding just how elastic Vibranium is. Captain America's Vibranium shield should have made any projectile ricochet away from him. Yet when Agent Carter attempted to demonstrate how durable it was by firing several rounds into it at close range, the shield flattened the bullets completely.

Excess radiation is another problem with Vibranium. It is said that the radiation emitted by the meteorite that brought Vibranium to Wakanda infused the soil and vegetation, prompting the growth of the Heart-Shaped Herb. The Wakandans of the MCU also use Vibranium as a power source in their cities. The idea of beneficial radiation that can alter plants and minerals but not the people and farm animals feeding on those plants is beyond impossible, even ignoring how the Black Panthers gain superpowers from eating the Heart-Shaped Herb.

7 Uru

Collaged images of jane Foster's Mighty Thor in the MCU.
Collaged images of jane Foster's Mighty Thor in the MCU.

Thor's hammer Mjölnir is said to be made of the mystic metal Uru in the comics. While not identified by that name in any MCU movie, Thor's description of how Mjölnir was "made from this special metal from the heart of a dying star" in Thor: Ragnarok is consistent with the comic book lore regarding it. Uru resembles stone but also has metallic properties. It is highly resistant to damage and is said to grow stronger when specially enchanted, having the unique property of absorbing magic like a sponge. This allows it to harness and redirect other energies, such as the lightning Thor channels as the God of Thunder.

6 Tony’s New Element

new element originally vibranium in iron man 2
new element originally vibranium in iron man 2

Suffering a slow death from radiation sickness after realizing the arc reactor in his chest was made of palladium, Tony Stark created a new element in Iron Man 2 to fashion a new, non-toxic arc reactor. Just what this element is has never been explained, although Tony did try to patent it under the name "badassium." It was called Vibranium in the Iron Man 2 novelization, but this didn't fit JARVIS' description of the substance as a new element. Whatever it was, the new metal had unusual energy absorption properties, allowing Tony to absorb Thor's lightning in The Avengers and block the power of the Mind Stone.

Usually, new elements can only be created using particle accelerators and nuclear reactions. While creating a new element is simple in theory, requiring the addition of protons or neutrons to an existing element, the process requires a lot of energy, and the resulting element is rarely stable for long. These new elements also tend to be incredibly radioactive, making it all but impossible for Tony Stark to create a non-radioactive element that is safer than palladium.

5 Pym Particles

Pym Particles

Created by Hank Pym, Pym Particles are subatomic particles that can increase or decrease the mass, density, and strength of physical matter. This is a violation of the Square-cube law of physics, which states that anything that becomes 10 times bigger would cover 100 times more surface area and weigh 1000 times as much. A real giant would break their legs trying to take a single step due to the weight of their body relative to the strength of human muscles and bones. Pym Particles overcome this by shifting the excess mass into the subatomic Quantum Realm. This is, simply put, impossible with real-world physics.

4 The Infinity Stones

Robert Downey Jr. as Tony Stark with Infinity Stones in 2019 Avengers Endgame
Robert Downey Jr. as Tony Stark with Infinity Stones in 2019 Avengers Endgame

Knowledge regarding the Infinity Stones' origins in the MCU is limited. Recent comic stories revealed they were the creation of the Celestials, the cosmic beings who created the MCU and several other universes. It was implied that the Infinity Stones grant phenomenal power, but that power can only be wielded according to the whims of the Celestials. This means that Thanos is as much a pawn of prophecy as anyone, which was also implied by the Sacred Timeline in Loki.

Sacred Timeline aside, the lore of the Infinity Stones within the MCU films is rather nonsensical. Granting that the stones are more mystic than scientific, it still seems that the Space and Time Stones should conform to the natural laws of science. For all the power the Stones have, their destruction doesn't seem to affect the MCU at all. There is also some question whether the Stones are sentient unto themselves, as the Soul Stone requires a sacrifice before revealing itself. If it is not the Stone itself requiring the sacrifice, who is running the show?

3 Gamma Waves

The Hulk in Thor

Bruce Banner was transformed into The Hulk after being exposed to gamma rays. In the real world, gamma radiation is the shortest wavelength of electromagnetic waves released by radioactive materials. They are also the deadliest, causing intense damage to tissue and DNA through even brief exposure. The MCU tried to hand-wave this somewhat while honoring the comic book lore, with Bruce Banner explaining to his cousin, She-Hulk Jennifer Walters, that they both had "a rare combination of genetic factors that allow us to synthesize gamma radiation into something else." While some people might be more resistant to radiation, nobody can alter radioactive energy in the body completely.

2 The Harvest DNA Serum

Nick Fury with the Harvest in Secret Invasion episode 6
Nick Fury with the Harvest in Secret Invasion episode 6

In Secret Invasion, the Harvest DNA Serum was an 11th-hour McGuffin, created to justify the Skrull Gravik going rogue and building an army intent on taking over the Earth. Nick Fury was revealed to have been collecting the DNA of various heroes and villains for years. All of this DNA was distilled into a single serum, dubbed Harvest, which could be used by a Skrull to give themselves the powers of multiple MCU characters, from Ghost to Groot.

There's no clear logic behind how the Harvest serum functions. Even allowing for G'iah and Gravik to somehow gain access to a list of every being whose DNA went into the serum, there's no way of intrinsically knowing how their powers would function. It also beggars belief that Nick Fury could somehow store all this genetic information in a single clear liquid, seemingly stored at room temperature.

1 Celestial Brain Fluid

celestial tiamut in eternals
celestial tiamut in eternals

In the comics, the blood and brain fluid of Celestials can be used to give a person superpowers. It is unclear if the same is true in the MCU, where the decapitated skull of a Celestial was turned into the city of Knowhere and became home to a massive mining operation. It is said that Knowhere harvests the bone, brain tissue, and spinal fluid of the dead Celestial, but it is unclear just what they use it for. It is also unclear why the Celestials would allow one of their numbers to be desecrated in this fashion if Celestial Brain Fluid is that powerful in the Marvel Cinematic Universe.