Rick Grimes will return to The Walking Dead universe after the confirmation of a spin-off series centering around him and Michonne. The protagonist hasn’t been seen since 2018 when he made the decision to sacrifice himself and somehow survived. While that choice was brave, Rick has made plenty of others that weren’t quite so smart.

These bad decisions range from Rick bringing on Negan’s wrath onto his group to his many attempts to win the Scavengers’ favor. There are several other instances where the protagonist’s decisions were either foolhardy or downright stupid, and forever altered the show's story.

Rick Blamed Lori For His Falling Out With Shane

Shane watching Rick and Lori in The Walking Dead
Shane watching Rick and Lori in The Walking Dead 

Rick is greatly disturbed at having to kill Shane, so much so that he decides to blame Lori for the falling out. While even fans consider this an unforgivable action in The Walking Dead, the truth is that it was dumb of Rick to see Lori as the reason.

After all, she never meant to turn the friends against each other, and her warning that Shane was dangerous was valid. Moreover, Rick was later beside himself with grief when Lori died because he never got to reconcile with her. Had he decided to forgive Lori instead of blaming her, Rick would have saved himself a world of hurt.

Rick's Self-Righteous Rant To The Community

Rick Grimes yelling and pointing a gun in The Walking Dead
Rick Grimes yelling and pointing a gun in The Walking Dead 

Rick’s hyper-emotional state after fighting Pete meant he made the silly decision to outright threaten the people of Alexandria. This happened after he had left subtle clues of wanting to take over because the Alexandrians were ill-equipped to face the dangers of the zombie-ridden world.

However, going on a self-righteous rant about how he was better than them and why they were weak was the wrong move. In fact, Michonne knocked Rick out just to shut him up, proving that Rick’s decision to be so open about his intentions was more stupid than brave.

Rick Forced People With Bad Blood To Get Along

Rick Grimes stopping a fight in The Walking Dead
Rick Grimes stopping a fight in The Walking Dead 

Carl's death was an event that permanently changed Rick in The Walking Dead, with the latter seeking to reach a peaceful resolution to the conflict with the Saviors. But this was a foolhardy move since Rick ignored the bad blood the Saviors had with the people at the Hilltop, Oceanside, and the Kingdom.

Rick essentially forced everyone to try and get along, which clearly didn’t work since the remaining Saviors had little remorse and continued to antagonize the others. It was a laughably bad decision all around, and one that didn’t remain intact after Rick’s disappearance since the Saviors were simply cast out.

Rick Saved Randall Instead Of Eliminating Him Straight Away

Rick and Shane bringing the abducted Randall with them in The Walking Dead
Rick and Shane bringing the abducted Randall with them in The Walking Dead 

Another one of Rick’s emotional but dumb decisions was to save the life of the Living member Randall, whom he never intended to let free. After defeating Randall’s group, Rick made the spur-of-the-moment decision to rescue him from walkers, only to then hold him captive.

The fact that Rick initially intended to execute Randall at the farm made saving him immaterial. In the end, Shane used his killing of Randall to lure Rick out. It wouldn’t have happened if Rick had just let Randall be eaten by the walkers, which the latter deserved for attacking Rick’s group in the first place.

Rick Didn't Retreat Back To Alexandria When Saviors Blocked The Road

Rick and his group standing by the RV in The Walking Dead
Rick and his group standing by the RV in The Walking Dead

The season 6 finale was a masterclass in boneheaded decisions on the part of Rick’s group, which enabled the Saviors to corner them. Rick decided to keep soldiering further to take Maggie to the Hilltop’s doctor even after the Saviors kept cutting them off on the road.

The simplest move would have been to turn back to Alexandria and be safe in their stronghold, but Rick’s recklessness meant he ordered his people to head farther ahead. This led to Negan’s men finally cornering and catching Rick’s group, ultimately resulting in the deaths of Glenn and Abraham.

Rick Slaughtered The Saviors Without Doing Any Recon On Who They Were

Rick and Daryl at the Savior Outpost in The Walking Dead
Rick and Daryl at the Savior Outpost in The Walking Dead

Rick accepted the position of a hired gun for the Hilltop when Gregory agreed to give Alexandria supplies in exchange for killing the Saviors. Then, Rick made the incredibly shortsighted decision to attack a Savior outpost that he believed contained all of them, not bothering to do a recon on how many there were.

This came back to haunt him big time since the outpost was just a checkpoint and the Saviors’ deaths brought the existence of Rick’s group to Negan’s attention. In essence, Rick’s decision to carry out the hit job led to Alexandria later being subjugated — all because he decided not to do a background check.

Rick Decided To Go Along With Shane's Obvious Ploy Instead Of Slaying Him

Rick and Shane in an open field in The Walking Dead
Rick and Shane in an open field in The Walking Dead 

Shane started out as Rick’s best friend in The Walking Dead before turning into his rival for Lori’s affections. Rick realized Shane was using the excuse of looking for Randall to get him into a secluded area to kill him, only to keep going with the charade until they finally clashed.

It was a silly move on Rick’s part since he was in an easy position to kill Shane without making a big show out of it. Moreover, killing Shane quietly would have guaranteed the farm’s safety — Carl had to shoot Shane as a walker to save Rick, which would’ve been avoided altogether had Rick eliminated Shane earlier.

Rick Left Sophia To Fend For Herself

Rick talking to Sophia in The Walking Dead
Rick talking to Sophia in The Walking Dead 

The dumbest decision Rick made earlier in the series was to believe that Sophia, a child, could ever fend for herself. Rick decided to leave Sophia on her own while he looked for the others, giving her relatively meaningless advice so she wouldn’t be lost.

Of course, that was too much to ask from a child in a world filled with flesh-eating zombies, and she eventually perished at the hands of a walker. Rick’s choice to leave Sophia was basically signing her death warrant and the sensible thing would have been to take her along to keep her safe.

Rick Tried To Win Jadis' Favor Even After The Scavengers' Betrayal

Rick talking to Jadis in The Walking Dead
Rick talking to Jadis in The Walking Dead 

Viewers were left scratching their heads when Rick decided to head to the Scavengers and convince them to fight against Negan — this happened after they had betrayed him. Jadis had reneged on the deal with Alexandria to aid Negan, yet Rick still went to them.

As expected, Jadis held Rick captive, and he still tried to win their favor. It was a dumb idea all around, especially since the Scavengers were known to be traitors and were among the most cringe-worthy parts of The Walking Dead. Nothing came out of this, as the Scavengers weren’t of any help to Rick, making all of it a giant waste of time.

Rick Shot The Final Savior At The Outpost Without Fully Confirming If He Was Negan

Rick talking to Fake Negan in The Walking Dead
Rick talking to Fake Negan in The Walking Dead

Rick’s arrogance clouded his decision-making after his group had eliminated all the Saviors at their outpost. He figured the remaining one had to be Negan, and didn’t think twice before shooting him dead, believing the Saviors were wiped out.

Of course, it turned out that Negan had brainwashed his people into the mantra of “We are Negan,” meaning Rick misconstrued the man’s words. Had Rick spent just a little more time interrogating the Savior, all the death and destruction at the real Negan’s hands could have been avoided.

NEXT: 10 Characters Who Must Appear In Rick & Michonne's Spinoff In The Walking Dead