Bones ran for twelve seasons, and though not every installment of the beloved crime procedural is perfect, the best episodes of the TV show outnumber the ones I'll never rewatch. However, that doesn't mean viewers who love Bones shouldn't critique some installments, or that there aren't episodes in most seasons that don't add to the overall story arc or character development.

Starring Emily Deschanel and David Boreanaz as Dr. Brennan and Agent Booth, Bones relied on the explosive chemistry between the two leads, which instantly set the series apart from the competition. The perfect Bones replacement TV shows all have their own will-they-won't-they dynamic, which can propel even the most predictable episodes of a procedural series. Though Bones always pushed itself to break the mold.

Both Emily Deschanel and David Boreanaz's favorite Bones episodes typically revolve around the most interesting cases and exciting developments in the relationship between Brennan and Booth. However, the weakest episodes all take the viewer out of the story, and often demonstrate the most dated aspects of Bones, which can be hard to watch through a contemporary lens.

7 The Strike In The Chord

Season 11, Episode 16

As Bones progressed, a lot changed about the show, and some of the episodes in the final seasons aren't as thrilling as the early installments. In season 11, "The Strike in the Chord" is an episode that audiences don't have to revisit, especially for viewers who aren't fans of a cappella. The episode revolves around a college a capella group, often poking fun at the activity.

Part of the issue with the later seasons was the departure of Sweets (John Francis Daley), who was killed off in season 10. Aubrey (John Boyd), the character who essentially replaces him, isn't a bad role, but Sweets' absence is acutely felt throughout episodes like "The Strike in the Chord." Without his insight, it feels like something's missing.

"The Strike in the Chord" doesn't explore any new territory when it comes to the investigation, and the way that Brennan treats her intern throughout the episode is hard to watch. Brennan has high standards throughout the show, but she's particularly harsh here. This doesn't uplift the A-story of the investigation and recalls a less-developed version of her character that had largely been left behind.

6 The Crank In The Shaft

Season 4, Episode 6

Bones season 4 saw the series experience some growing pains. After Zack (Eric Millegan) was written off in the season 3 finale following his devastating betrayal, the series had to make some changes in the fourth installment. This meant that some of these episodes are weaker, since the series is still finding its feet all over again. This comes through in "The Crank in the Shaft."

"The Crank in the Shaft" leans much more heavily into the comedic side of the storytelling.

Bones is a light-hearted crime drama TV show that leans into the comedic elements of its storylines. However, audiences were initially drawn into the story because of its more frightening and tense aspects of the investigations. "The Crank in the Shaft" leans much more heavily into the comedic side of the storytelling, especially since it turns out almost every supporting character wasn't a fan of the victim.

While Bones often has an exploration that's a little too convenient when wrapping up the investigations, this is especially true in "The Crank in the Shaft." Additionally, Booth's obsession with status in the FBI isn't a compelling B-story, as there's little connection between this and the main murder he and Brennan are solving. There's in "The Crank in the Shaft" that can't be found in better episodes.

5 The Carrot In The Kudzu

Season 9, Episode 18

The later seasons of Bones start to see an increase in episodes that focus on Booth and Brennan's domestic life and how they operate as a family. Like most TV shows that rely on a central will-they-won't-they romance, Bones lost some steam after the couple finally got together, as the biggest source of tension in the series dissipated after this.

While it's sweet to see them raising a family together, episodes like "The Carrot in the Kudzu" just aren't as exciting as the peak seasons of the series. The premise of the story is also a little goofy on its own, as it focuses on a children's performer who's known for dressing up as a carrot. Bones often juxtaposes the comedic with the morbid.

However, it doesn't always land throughout the episode, as the discoveries that the children's entertainer wasn't as innocent as he seemed are predictable. The secondary storylines of the children's birthday party and Clark's (Eugene Byrd) novel are ultimately forgettable, making "The Carrot in the Kudzu" an easy installment to skip, even if audiences are watching the series for the first time.

4 The Priest In The Churchyard

Season 2, Episode 17

Religion is a recurring theme in Bones, as Booth and Brennan have opposite viewpoints when it comes to god, faith, and the importance of spirituality. In the early seasons, this dichotomy between their ideologies sparks some great tension between the will-they-won't-they couple, but "The Priest in the Churchyard" doesn't explore this as well as other episodes.

There are some great romantic stakes between Booth and Brennan throughout "The Priest in the Churchyard," but the series quickly moves on from this, and the events of the episode don't change anything about their relationship. Additionally, the central murder is one of the least exciting of the series, taking a back seat to some of the personal issues that have been rehashed many times throughout the series.

The relationships between both Booth and Brennan and Angela and Hodgins are on display in "The Priest in the Churchyard."

The relationships between both Booth and Brennan and Angela and Hodgins are on display in "The Priest in the Churchyard," but there's no new information in the story. While "The Priest in the Churchyard" isn't a terrible episode, it's stalling time before the exciting conclusion of season 2 can fully heat up, as Brennan's arc with her father is the biggest plot point of the season.

3 The He In The She

Season 4, Episode 7

This episode demonstrates many of the elements of Bones that were of their time in the 2000s, but that doesn't make it easier to watch. Following the identification of a transgender victim, Bones crosses into some offensive territory throughout "The He in the She," an episode that already has a problematic title. From there, Bones makes many missteps in its attempts to engage with an LGBTQ+ character.

For 2008, the identity politics of the episode could have been worse, but they're still too dated to be considered respectful by today's standards. Though "The He in the She" does seemingly come down on the side of tolerance and love by the end of the episode, there are many moments when the victim is misgendered, making for some uncomfortable and upsetting scenes.

It's not unexpected that a procedural from the early 2000s doesn't provide good representation for trans characters, but that doesn't mean it's worth revisiting the episode. Though Booth and Brennan have an interesting back-and-forth about religion, that doesn't make up for the rest of the story. As Bones progressed, the writing became more nuanced in other situations, but this installment is one that's better forgotten.

Title

Rotten Tomatoes Critic Score

Rotten Tomatoes Audience Score

Bones (2005–2017)

86%

83%

2 The Diamond In The Rough

Season 8, Episode 10

As the seasons progressed, Bones leaned into the storylines that saw Booth and Brennan forced to go undercover in slightly silly situations. "The Diamond in the Rough" sees the pair pretend to be professional dancers in a ballroom competition. Though both Boreanaz and Deschanel hold their own with the choreography, it's clear they're a little uncomfortable.

Brennan's lack of skill on the dance floor is part of the plot, but the comedic elements of going undercover undermine some of the tension of the murder investigation. Though Bones is a crime procedural that keeps things on the lighter side most of the time, the dancing can get a little cringeworthy at times.

When it comes to the murder investigation, this is far from Booth and Brennan's most difficult or interesting case, with the story unfolding as the audience might expect. Back at the lab, the most interesting part of the work is seeing Hodgins and Wendall find a way to decrystallize the skeleton. Though not a terrible watch, "The Diamond in the Rough" isn't anything special.

1 The Ghost In The Machine

Season 8, Episode 9

Episodes that blur the line between spirituality and science are always interesting challenges for TV shows like Bones. Season 8, episode 9, "The Ghost in the Machine," draws inspiration from other experimental episodes of television, like M*A*S*H's "Point of View." In "The Ghost in the Machine," most of the story unfolds from the perspective of the bones, with the characters speaking directly to the skeleton.

It's implied that the victim's soul is still with the remains, and a psychic is even folded into the story to commune with the dead. While the importance of hope and faith in support of science does come into play in Bones, this is a little too out there. Audiences tune into Bones because of its unique forensic perspective and character relationships.

While the shifting point of view is an interesting idea, Bones doesn't execute it perfectly.

Out of every season of Bones, season 8 does have its weak points, but this episode stands out all the more compared to the rest of the season. While the shifting point of view is an interesting idea, Bones doesn't execute it perfectly. There are a few creative choices, like the scene transitions, that make the story feel more like a gimmick than an emotional exploration of loss.

0315901_poster_w780.jpg
74
9.4/10

Bones

Release Date
2005 - 2017-00-00
Network
FOX
Showrunner
Hart Hanson
Directors
Ian Toynton, Dwight H. Little, Chad Lowe, Jeannot Szwarc, Allan Kroeker, Kate Woods, Steven DePaul, Tim Southam, Jeff Woolnough, Milan Cheylov, Randall Zisk, Alex Chapple, François Velle, Jesús Salvador Treviño, Tony Wharmby, Craig Ross Jr., Kevin Hooks, Michael Lange, Sanford Bookstaver, Allison Liddi-Brown, David Grossman, Emile B. Levisetti, Greg Yaitanes, Brad Turner
Writers
Hart Hanson, Michael Peterson, Dean Lopata, Jonathan Collier, Keith Foglesong, Janet Lin, Elizabeth Benjamin, Pat Charles, Josh Berman, Scott Williams, Hilary Weisman Graham, Noah Hawley, Lyla Oliver, Karyn Usher, Dave Thomas, Janet Tamaro, Sanford Golden, Steve Blackman, Joe Hortua, Karen Wyscarver, Nkechi Okoro Carroll, Emily Silver, Yael Zinkow, Greg Ball
  • Headshot Of Emily Deschanel
    Emily Deschanel
    Temperance 'Bones' Brennan
  • Headshot Of David Boreanaz
    Seeley Booth