Warning: This article contains SPOILERS for Smile 2

Although Smile 2’s twist ending is ingenious, it also sets up a major problem for Smile 3. Smile 2 manages to take director Parker Finn’s sleeper hit from 2022 and expand on the twisty psychological horror in numerous ways. While Smile focused on a mental health professional who was cursed after witnessing the death of her patient, Smile 2 centers on Naomi Scott’s glamorous pop star Skye Riley as she struggles against the franchise’s demonic villain. Smile 2’s Skye is based on real-life musicians, but her eventual fate is fortunately not one shared by any entertainment industry stars.

In Smile 2’s ending, Skype realizes that she has been trapped in an exhausting hallucination for an almost unknowable amount of time as the demonic entity wears down her defenses. Unable to stop the demon anymore, she finally succumbs to the monster while onstage at a concert. Smile 2’s twist ending should be predictable, since viewers guessed that the sequel would end with an entire concert’s worth of witnesses being cursed when Smile 2’s premise was first announced. However, Finn's misdirections manage to make the twist surprising, and it is a genuinely grim shock when Skye dies onstage.

Smile 2’s Ending Forces Smile 3 To Explain What Happens To Multiple Witnesses

Thousands Of Concertgoers See Naomi Scott’s Skye Riley Die

However, Finn’s killer sequel ending has left the Smile franchise in a tricky position. The question posed by Smile 2’s ending is whether every witness gets cursed simultaneously or not, and it is almost impossible to work out a satisfying answer. Presumably, every witness saw Skye die, which means they all get cursed at the same time. However, this would be pandemonium. Furthermore, the sudden onslaught of mass death could easily be traced back to the concert in Smile 3’s story. While Smile 2’s monster is slightly different from the original movie, it seems to operate the same.

The concert ending of Smile 2 leaves the demon with countless potential victims, but Smile 3’s insular story can’t focus on all of them at once.

The Smile demon wears down its victims over a matter of days, subjecting them to increasingly elaborate hallucinations that eventually lead them to take their own lives. However, until now, the demon has done this to one victim at a time. The pattern is so consistent that characters in both movies could track the demon’s progress by looking back through death records. The concert ending of Smile 2 leaves the demon with countless potential victims, but Smile 3’s insular story can’t focus on all of them at once. What makes the Smile movies so scary is their singular perspective.

Why Smile 3 Having Multiple Victims Would Be So Problematic

The Smile Franchise’s Formula Needs A Singular Focus To Succeed

The Smile movies need to center on one victim since they take place inside their heroes's heads. Smile 2 killed off Joel early so the sequel had a fresh perspective, but its sequel can’t be about thousands of people at once. In fact, an ending similar to Smile 2’s twist ending already killed another iconic horror franchise when 2017’s Rings didn’t know how to follow its similar twist. That reboot ended with the cursed video going viral and, despite its box office success, never received a sequel. Now, Smile 3 must find a way for Smile 2 to avoid the same fate.

Smile 2 is currently playing in theaters.

01870910_poster_w780.jpg
Smile 2
60
8.5/10
Release Date
October 16, 2024

Cast
Rosemarie DeWitt, Naomi Scott, Lukas Gage, Miles Gutierrez-Riley, Peter Jacobson, Ray Nicholson, Dylan Gelula, Raul Castillo, Kyle Gallner, Drew Barrymore, Zebedee Row, Roberts Jekabsons, Sean Stolzen, Jon Rua, Vladimir Duthiers, Kristine Johnson, Christopher Bailey, Ivan Carlo, Christopher Sky, Jarrett Austin Brown, Erika Chase, Karma Jenkins, Daphne Zelle, Brandi Bravo
Runtime
127 minutes
Director
Parker Finn
Distributor(s)
Paramount Pictures