Amazon's new series Utopia might be a remake of the UK series with the same name, but the show is basically unwatchable after stripping out everything that made the original so great. Utopia had the misfortune of centering around a massive pandemic, paranoid conspiracy theorists that are proved right, and a group of fringe comic book fans - and has nothing new or interesting to say about any of those things. While the original Utopia was a stylish dark comedy about conspiracies in a science-fiction world, the straightforward Amazon remake strikes exactly the wrong note.

The Utopia remake follows a group of comic book fans who believe that the "Dystopia" graphic novel predicted major world disasters, including Zika and the Ebola epidemic. After the long-awaited sequel "Utopia" is found, the kids find themselves on the run with Jessica Hyde, the graphic novel's protagonist who turns out to be real. The show features plot-lines about a national flu pandemic, tainted vaccines that might destroy humanity, and a web of conspiracy theories that turns out to be true. Utopia stripped down the UK cult series to the basic premise and created an entirely different - and much worse - show.

Related: Why Utopia's Reviews Are So Mixed

The American remake of Utopia has been in progress for years, first as a David Fincher project for HBO, and eventually finding a home at Amazon with Gillian Flynn (Sharp Objects, Gone Girl) as showrunner. The original Utopia is unambiguously great, blending a gorgeous, bright visual style with dark comedy and a ruthless examination of comic books and their obsessive fans. Amazon's Utopia remake focused on all the wrong things, and sucked all the joy and whimsy out of the original while also premiering at the worst possible time. Utopia is impossible to watch without thinking of real-life events and simultaneously has nothing important to say - and that's just one of the reasons the remake is so unwatchable.

Amazon's Utopia Lost What Made The Original Special

Utopia

The original Utopia was praised for the stunning visuals. It had a distinctly Technicolor palette, styling the series like a graphic novel with oversaturated colors and offbeat framing. This was part of what made the UK series great, contrasting the dark content with a beautifully shot world that almost felt like a fantasy. Amazon's Utopia discards the UK's striking visuals entirely, painting the series in muted colors and turning the world into something dreary and plain, with nothing making the show distinct. Instead of contrasting the grim material with the shimmering, joyful world, the remake doubles down on the dourness and washes everything down until Utopia looks the same as every other gritty, prestige show.

Discarding one of the best parts of the UK series - it's bright, distinct style - was the first red flag that Amazon's remake stripped Utopia down to the bones and focused on all the wrong things. Where the original Utopia was a dark comedy, Amazon gets rid of the comedy entirely, making a show so serious that the occasional joke is jarring. Utopia completely abandons the humor and whimsy of the original and focuses instead on trying to shock the audience with how violent it is, which only hides the fact that Utopia never has anything interesting to say.

Utopia Released At The Wrong Time

Rainn Wilson as Michael Stearns Amazon Prime Utopia

A major part of Utopia is a storyline about a flu pandemic quickly spreading across the United States, as part of Dr. Kevin Christie's conspiracy to end overpopulation and save the planet. Although the original Utopia had a pandemic storyline, it was a much smaller part of the series - and the remake instead turns the Stearns flu into one of the biggest plots in the show. The UK Utopia aired from 2013 to 2014 and didn't premiere during a pandemic, and the flu storyline felt much more like science-fiction at the time than it does now. In addition, the series was focused far more on the mythology surrounding the "Utopia" graphic novel and developing its characters - not on the impact of a pandemic in the United States.

Related: Utopia Soundtrack Guide: Every Song In Season 1

Amazon's Utopia was written and filmed before the coronavirus pandemic, and tries to make it clear that the series is not supposed to be a commentary on current events. As a result, Utopia's focus on the flu pandemic comes off as incredibly tone-deaf, and despite the warning at the beginning of every episode, it's impossible to watch the series without comparing it to real-life. Because Utopia was created before the coronavirus, it doesn't have anything meaningful or necessary to say about the pandemic - but it also doesn't function as escapism anymore, leaving the series in a monotonous middle ground where it both premiered at the worst possible time and doesn't feel like science-fiction anymore.

Utopia's Advantage Was Being A Comic Book Show Before They Were Cool

Utopia

When Utopia was airing in 2013 before its sudden cancellation, its focus on the world of comic books and their obsessive fans felt groundbreaking, like peering into an underground world that wasn't yet discovered. Premiering one year after The Avengers, Utopia was great because it was at the forefront of the comic book trend, and its sharp examination of the superhero industry was breaking new ground. Amazon's Utopia suffers from premiering in the aftermath of billion-dollar superhero franchises, in a world where comic books are no longer fringe - but sanitized, monetized, and analyzed to death. If Utopia frequently feels like an outdated examination of comic books and their fans, that's because it is.

Utopia's critique of comic books and the superhero industry is a mess because the series can't figure out what it wants to say. In episode 1, Sam says to a group of "Dystopia" fanboys who tell her that her conspiracy theories are crazy that, "a group of you f**king boy a**holes managed to trick the world into believing that comic books are serious f**king literature." Sam's monologue, like most of Utopia, is written in a way that sounds insightful, but actually says nothing: Utopia is trying to simultaneously argue that comic books aren't serious and that a comic book will save the world. Unlike Amazon's The Boys, which is a much sharper examination of the industry, Utopia is trying to make too many different points at once, and ends up missing the point entirely.

Ultimately, Amazon's remake of Utopia makes major changes to the UK original and ends up being a boring, grim show with nothing interesting to say. Unlike the UK Utopia, which was a bright and whimsical examination of comic book fandom and real-life conspiracies, the remake makes the world darker and grimmer, and can't figure out what it's trying to argue in the first place. Utopia loses sight of what made the original show great, and manages to feel both eerily prescient and completely out of touch with reality. To quote Dr. Kevin Christie's constant refrain throughout the series: Utopia didn't earn its place in this crowded world.

Next: What To Expect From Utopia Season 2